Whats going with CD's and DR,DL ratings???

by Wigo, Dec 28, 2022

hey managers,

for last couples of weeks i am spending days and testing best tactics from the table and comparing how is it working... tactics are great teams are overachieving massively all great! But what annoys me is every single test with underdog or top team doesnt matter CD players ratings are below average! DR-DL position as well... if your cd scores from corner ok that game he as 7+ rating, but if not they are mostly like 6.3 - 6.5... ive tried so many combinations and no luck to make CD's consistently get at least 6.8-7.0 ratings... aany one on the same pattern? :)

0

P.s. In one of my (Quick) best defensive test as liverpool in 22 games i concede 9 goals. in pair was van dyjk and konate... and even after such a great team performance, Konate average rating was 6.5. my blame for stupid match engine :/

0

Bear in mind the ratings are tied to the results.

If you play with the worst team in the league and you lose every match then the ratings of your players will be very low 4.0 - 5.0 ( across the positions )

If you play with the best team in the league and you win every match then the ratings of your players will be very high 8.0 - 9.0 ( across the positions )

If some positions in your tactic get lower ratings than other positions then you can do nothing about it because it works the way the devs tuned the ratings the positions.

Btw, the devs might tune the ratings from patch to patch.

0

Wigo said: hey managers,

for last couples of weeks i am spending days and testing best tactics from the table and comparing how is it working... tactics are great teams are overachieving massively all great! But what annoys me is every single test with underdog or top team doesnt matter CD players ratings are below average! DR-DL position as well... if your cd scores from corner ok that game he as 7+ rating, but if not they are mostly like 6.3 - 6.5... ive tried so many combinations and no luck to make CD's consistently get at least 6.8-7.0 ratings... aany one on the same pattern? :)


Full-backs mainly get their ratings from crosses completed I find, so roles like IWB rarely do well. A lot of a CBs rating is taken from aerial duel win %. If your CBs are on the near post at corners, they won't win that many headers as corners have been nerfed.

0

This is a problem i have noticed too. Maybe SI developers include some factors and maybe complicated factors for each position to be able to get high average ratings. Or this is a bug which will updated in next patch. Maybe this year we have the worst ME in FM history.

I have tested many tactics, mine and others, and the most goals i have conceded were from one way(central positions - penalty box) which may represent real life football but as someone says in SI official forum, we have to play defensively against weaker teams so we can win matches, with whatever team we manage. This is not real.

I can't imagine for example Man City to play defensively in away matches with Fulham, Nottingham Forest etc, including home matches too. There are many users that say that their teams have 30 shots and no one go inside and the weaker team get 2 goals from counter attacks so easily. If this scenario happens once in every 15-20 matches(with weaker teams) it will be okay as it will represent the real football but this is more often.

Thats why we struggle to get a very well balanced team and we have to reduce mentality of tactics.

0
Create an account or log in to leave a comment