FM27 match engine: what we know so far

And here are some suggested genie scout values based on the pooled results.

ST
Pace 100, Acceleration 92, Jumping Reach 79, Anticipation 46, Stamina 43, Finishing 37, Balance 32, Strength 30, Concentration 23, Important Matches 22, Dribbling 20, Pressure 90 (fixed from 18 based on GeorgeFloydOverdosed comment below) , Heading 14

AM (AML / AMC / AMR)
Pace 100, Acceleration 80, Jumping Reach 50, Strength 49, Stamina 45, Anticipation 36, Dribbling 35, Finishing 33, Concentration 27, Long Shots 25, Pressure 120 (fixed from 24 based on GeorgeFloydOverdosed comment below) , Balance 19, Determination 18, Heading 16

FB / WB (DL/DR, WBL/WBR)
Pace 100, Acceleration 83, Stamina 61, Dribbling 41, Anticipation 34, Jumping Reach 33, Concentration 30, Strength 28, Important Matches 21, Long Shots 20, Balance 19

DM
Acceleration 100, Pace 64, Stamina 49, Jumping Reach 38, Strength 33, Agility 25, Anticipation 24

CB (DC)
Jumping Reach 100, Acceleration 86, Pace 62, Balance 34, Stamina 33, Anticipation 30, Concentration 20, Strength 20, Work Rate 16, Important Matches 15, Pressure 70 (fixed from 14 based on GeorgeFloydOverdosed comment below)

GK
Agility 100, Reflexes 91, Aerial Reach 30, Acceleration 21, Concentration 18, Important Matches 11, Anticipation 10
 
Last edited:
Just keep in mind that aside from the calculation bugs that plague Genie Scout, personality attributes are weighted at 20% internally. So Pressure 18 should become Pressure 90.
I've seen repeated claims about this (not from you) that were based on code from an old tool that was wrongly claimed to be Genie Scout. What I haven't seen is actual code from GS. I'm therefore skeptical about what its doing in the rating calculation. It does use personality attributes in the probability of development.
 
I've seen repeated claims about this (not from you) that were based on code from an old tool that was wrongly claimed to be Genie Scout. What I haven't seen is actual code from GS. I'm therefore skeptical about what its doing in the rating calculation. It does use personality attributes in the probability of development.
I know the thread that was on FM Arena you're probably talking about. This is not that.

I arrived at this conclusion about Genie Scout through my own analysis of it. You can deduce it by only weighting one thing at a time, and observing the effects. You'll find personality attributes are weighted and capped at 20%, while the way it calculates things just does not add up.. you can have a player be better than another in every way, and yet that player inexplicably has a lower rating. Even when 2 players are identical (you can do this by weighting only 1 attribute), one will be +0.2% say. The errors are relatively minor, but it matters when you're trying to accurately distinguish to within ~1%, with your own error on top of that - effectively the error ends up being more like 3-5%. And this is aside from the inbuilt proficiency and footedness weights, which are reasonable, but that you cannot change.
 
Last edited:
I know the thread that was on FM Arena you're probably talking about. This is not that.

I arrived at this conclusion about Genie Scout through my own analysis of it. You can deduce it by only weighting one thing at a time, and observing the effects. You'll find personality attributes are weighted and capped at 20%, while the way it calculates things just does not add up.. you can have a player be better than another in every way, and yet that player inexplicably has a lower rating. Even when 2 players are identical (you can do this by weighting only 1 attribute), one will be +0.2% say. The errors are relatively minor, but it matters when you're trying to accurately distinguish to within ~1%, with your own error on top of that - effectively the error ends up being more like 3-5%. And this is aside from the inbuilt proficiency and footedness weights, which are reasonable, but that you cannot change.
I understand your point, but there is a logic behind limiting the impact of pressure. Most of the time pressure has zero impact, and when it does it works by reducing other attributes like composure , decisions, and concentration. Two of those 3 things are literally weighted zero and the third Caio has suggested weights of 20-30. Its just my opinion, but I think putting pressure up at 80-100 would just be be saying that you think consistency 20 and pressure 1 is the same as consistency 1 and pressure 20. Logically that cant be true because pressure of 1 only reduces consistency for a small part of the game, and the consistency 1 player will be bad the whole game.
 
I understand your point, but there is a logic behind limiting the impact of pressure. Most of the time pressure has zero impact, and when it does it works by reducing other attributes like composure , decisions, and concentration. Two of those 3 things are literally weighted zero and the third Caio has suggested weights of 20-30. Its just my opinion, but I think putting pressure up at 80-100 would just be be saying that you think consistency 20 and pressure 1 is the same as consistency 1 and pressure 20. Logically that cant be true because pressure of 1 only reduces consistency for a small part of the game, and the consistency 1 player will be bad the whole game.
I don't know where you've heard those things from, I can only assume from recent reverse-engineering.

Be that so or not, I trust results more than theory, because the game can be faulty but results are self-evident. Good example of this is how recently we're learning how ornate the match engine is, but at the end of the day pace/acc dominates and almost every technical makes no difference to outcomes.

Orion's results from 2022:

Fn2o6rT.png


It remained true for FM24 based on testing myself and HarvestGreen did, so I imagine it's the same for FM27.

And in fact all I've said is that if caiograco finds that Pressure is 18 weight in FM27, then the way to represent that properly in Genie Scout is to multiply it by 5.
 
The numbers I shared are from moving attributes from 12-18. Things change if we go all the way to 1. In particular, pressure works on finishing, which in turn influences whether xG becomes goals. At pressure of 1, most xG becomes wasted chances.

Here is a similar graph from my tests.
1794886778251.webp


What i don't have is tests at a more granular detail, from 1 to 20. And the estimates above could also be updated with more tests, but the patterns is the same as in previous games.
 
Back
Top