My review of every FM24 skin

by GeorgeFloydOverdosed, 5 days, 14 hours ago

Reviewed with resolution of 1440p

5 or above is good/playable
3-4 may even be great in some ways but has serious issues
1-2 trash

I am strongly inclined towards a default-style skin, but I've tried to be somewhat open-minded.

My criteria is:

font
clarity
responsiveness
hidden attributes (footedness, CA/PA, personality, instant result, fitness %, etc.)
lack of crowdedness
stadium imagery
info/data
lack of logo intrusiveness
comfyness
face size
lack of bugs

For score 6 or less, I just went with overall initial impressions, with the criteria in mind.

WTCS Gold 24 1.3.1 - 7.64
Sas2025Final-Hidden - 7.09
Dark Polish FM24 Skins v7 - 7.09
Chove Skin for FM24 - 7.09
FusionDB FM24 Classic Dark v1.1 - 7.00


--------------

Make FM24 Better Skin v2.5 Desktop - 6
FM.Zweierkette Skin v24.0.55 - 6
Kojuro Skin v6.2.0 - 6
Cheetah Skin 24.1.3 - 6
FM24 Light Skin - 5 or 6 (with fixes)
Tato24 FM24 Skin 2.0 - 5
Classics24 1.3 - 5
Classics24 Dark Version 1.4 - 5
DoubleX Skin - 5
Vincechup FM24 Skin - 5
LIVID 24 - 5
Zealand Skin FM24 - 5
Default skin - 5

--------------

Trung FM24 Skin v1.7 - 4
Jimbo Skin 3.0.1 - 4
Rensie Dark FM24 Skin - 4
NY Light FM24 - 4
Electric Panther - Mustermann Edition - v1.2.0 - 4
Echo Skin for FM24 - 4
OPZ Elite 2024 Blackout 2k (for 1440p) 19.3.0 - 3
Vince Skin 1.2 - 3
Mixed Skin 24.4.1 - 3
Statman FM24 Skin v1.5 - 3
TangFu Skin V24.3.0 - 3
Statman - NUMBERLESS v1.02 - 3
JMFM Base Skin24 2.0 - 3
Royal Crown Skin by Vasf 2025-04-13 - 3

--------------

Mustermann Iconic v1.2 FM24 Dark - 2
FM 2024 Flut Skin Dark 9.0 - 2
Just 24 - 2
Andromeda FM24 Final - 2
Vince Skin 1.2 Star Attributes - 2
Material Skin 2.0.24 V2.0.1 - 2
NARIGON Skin FM24 V1.00 - 2
Dark Gold FM24 Skin v2 - 2
Just 24 Attributeless - 1
Mixed Skin 24.4.1 (Colored) - 1
Priisek Retro 24 Skin Updated 30.12.24 The Final Cut - 1
Ciki Skin FM24 Skin - 1
Enganche Light Skin for FM24 - 1
Priisek Green 24 Skins Updated 30.12.24 - 1
FM24 in 25 LIVERPOOL Edition - 1
Fusion Skin FM24 - 1

1

thanks for this - SAS was always my favourite personally

0

Thanks for this post - please can I ask you which skin did you find had the largest player faces (e.g. when you check attributes)?  Or is there any skin that would allow you to fit in a whole shot of a player instead of just the player face?

Also is there any way to get player faces in-match  (so rather than seeing player shirt numbers you see the player faces?).  Thanks

0

Alxy said: Thanks for this post - please can I ask you which skin did you find had the largest player faces (e.g. when you check attributes)?  Or is there any skin that would allow you to fit in a whole shot of a player instead of just the player face?

Also is there any way to get player faces in-match  (so rather than seeing player shirt numbers you see the player faces?).  Thanks


For face size:

WTCS Gold 24 1.3.1 - 9
Sas2025Final-Hidden - 4 (what brought this skin down from no. 1 for me)
Dark Polish FM24 Skins v7 - 6
FusionDB FM24 Classic Dark v1.1 - 9
Chove Skin for FM24 - 9

Tato is a popular skin I didn't rate highly, I gave it 5 for face size.

In my view, WTCS 'profile' page for viewing attributes is usable as your default attribute view page, unlike many skins were its just too cluttered. And I like that it gives you 4 different options (i.e. face with kit behind, or just face, etc.)

Chove has perhaps the biggest face for attribute + profile pages (and its centered on profile page), but its quite non-vanilla.

FusionDB is smallish on profile page, but large on attribute page.

I definitely didn't see any skin with full body, and to me face pic can be too big because it just stretches it too big at a certain point (though I only used the sortitoutsi pack).

I took into account 2 other minor face things when giving my overall score btw, which is face icons on squad list screen, and big photos of the board members on the club vision screen. Many skins don't have either of these at all.

1

Thank you so much!

I want to give FM24 a decent try (I played a bit of vanilla FM24 before giving up) but I'd always wonder if there was maybe a "better" skin...and also best to settle on a skin before getting really into a save.

I also wasn't sure what a "better" skin was for me but after dabbling with FM26 interface helped me decide what I was after (less clutter, bigger graphic). 

I'd checked a few "best fm24 skin" youtube vids and did not come across Chove in any of them. 

Based on your comment above I've loaded it up and I like it and will stick with it.

Great post.  Well-timed.  Thank you again.

0
Create an account or log in to leave a comment