How FM-Arena picks tactics for the testing

by Alexander, Nov 9, 2021

Greetings,

First of all, I want say that we don't promise to test every tactic posted so don't expect that.

There are many factors influencing our decision on whether or not to test a tactic. Here are some of the factors:



Sharing a new tactic ( starting a new thread ).
- The better presentation of your tactic, the more likely it gets tested so don't be lazy and add screenshots of your tactic and some results with it, also, any additional useful information about your tactic. The more reasons you give why your tactic should be tested, the higher chances it gets tested.

- If your tactic is based on someone else's tactic or you take some elements from other tactic then you should state that in the description and give proper credit otherwise it won't get tested. Also, explain the difference between the original tactic and your tweak.

- It's unlikely that we test your tactic if we find it's very similar to what that has been tested already.

- When you propose someone else's tactic for the testing then please, post your own result with it.



Adding a new version/tactic in an already existing thread.
- When you add a new version/tactic in the existing thread then let everyone to know about it.

- Explain what changes you made.

- Add all essential information about the new version in the opening post(the 1st post) of the thread so that people can easily find the information about all your tactics/versions in the thread.

- For a new versions it also requires providing results with it.

- It's unlikely that we test a new version of your tactic if we find that the changes are too insignificant to make any meaningful difference.




Quantity vs Quality
Please notice that there's a reasonable limit on how many tested tactics one person can have. At the moment we find that about 10 tested tactics per one person is an optimal number so if you're above the limit then your further tactics has a low chance to get tested but it's still possible they get tested but that will depend on many different factors such as great attention from the community which means a lot people use it with a great success and share their results.

We find that having the limit is necessary because we don't want to encourage tacticians to do "brute-force cracking" of the match engine by spamming tactics without putting any intelligent thoughts behind them and we don't want to encourage tacticians to produce tactics that bring nothing new to the table. We'd like to see people do an analysis of what has been tested already before offering their tactics for the testing but of course, if we see that some tactic gets very positive feedback from the community then we'll test that tactic no matter what.

5

Here's an example how the opening post ( the 1st post of the thread ) should look like.

Of course, you can add more information/description and make it prettier but essential information should be present.


"Your Tactic Name" V1

[ Required Screenshots: Tactic / Result ]




"Your Tactic Name" V2

Changes:

- Mentality: Positive > Attacking
- Wingers(S) > Inside Forward(A)

[ Required Screenshots: Tactic / Result ]




"Your Tactic Name" V3

Changes:

- Mentality: Attacking > Very Attacking
- Shadow Striker(A) > Deep Lying Forward(S)

[ Required Screenshots: Tactic / Result ]

4
Create an account or log in to leave a comment