Set piece testing

by Mark, Jan 16, 2024

pixar said: Could the results change if we tested the base tactic with a different formation?

It is possible. But I am not sure it is probable given the changes to set pieces this year. Feel free to give it a go if you want.

1

Any thoughts on the default selection of players for various set piece roles?  I noticed that aerial threats seem to be selected based on an average of jumping reach, heading and strength, but this does not seem optimal.  Jumping reach seems much more important than the other two; some level of heading is needed to get the ball on target, but I can’t tell if strength has any benefit at all.

1

MeanOnSunday said: Any thoughts on the default selection of players for various set piece roles?  I noticed that aerial threats seem to be selected based on an average of jumping reach, heading and strength, but this does not seem optimal.  Jumping reach seems much more important than the other two; some level of heading is needed to get the ball on target, but I can’t tell if strength has any benefit at all.

Corner Taking is pretty much corners and which foot they are using, depends on whether I am after an inswinger or outswinger. I usually select Aerial Threats on Jumping Reach given the attribute testing on this site. Then Creators on Technique and Recovery Defenders on Pace. I also take into account where the players need to end up after the set piece and order of priority. For instance I wouldn't have my best aerial threat taking a corner just because he had the best corner delivery.

0

@smigler asked for Chicken Wing v1.8 to be tested

Here are the updated results



The Original Post will also be updated

2

@Gerrard requested I test his Azure V3 routine. It has now been tested and included in the results on the opening post. It did very well under my rating system finishing 3rd.

0

Thanks for testing

1

Brilliant stuff. Thanks.

0

Mark said: @smigler asked for Chicken Wing v1.8 to be tested

Here are the updated results



The Original Post will also be updated


So i see that best set pieces comes from Han 106 Bests Hits (best Goals from Corner, and Best Goal against from corner) :)
Where could i find these set pieces ? :)

Thanks for your work :thup:

0

hey @Mark  where did you get the Katana set pieces from? I don't remember uploading any SP for it

0

CBP87 said: hey @Mark  where did you get the Katana set pieces from? I don't remember uploading any SP for it

That is just the base, ie no set piece loaded.

1

Stevenel said: So i see that best set pieces comes from Han 106 Bests Hits (best Goals from Corner, and Best Goal against from corner) :)
Where could i find these set pieces ? :)

Thanks for your work :thup:



All the set pieces tested are uploaded under their own threads in the Set Piece Sharing Section

2

Thanks Mark :)

1

Hi Mark, great work on this!

I was wondering if you're still active and would be willing to test a few set-piece routines I found online (from FM-Gamers & FM-Base) to see how they rank on your testing table. If you're up for it, I'll attach them here in advance. Of course, full credit and shout-out to the original creators!

Thanks!

Rui.fmf
Downloaded : 92 times
Uploaded : Sep 13, 2024
666-周周定位球组合10.fmf
Downloaded : 111 times
Uploaded : Sep 13, 2024
0

Is Blue or Azure V3 the best set piece schedule?

0

max 737 said: Is Blue or Azure V3 the best set piece schedule?

As per the opening post, I have Blue on top but not a lot between the top 6 routines

1

Can you please advise me how to check goals from set pieces? Many thanks!

0

max 737 said: Can you please advise me how to check goals from set pieces? Many thanks!

Competition page => click on the comp name => stats => team detailed
On the left side, scroll down to the attacking section and you will see goals from corners, goals from direct free kicks and so on.

0

max 737 said: Is Blue or Azure V3 the best set piece schedule?

Azure scores more often, but also concedes more often. Blue scores less often from corners, and concedes less overall.

0

I still haven't found which is the best set pieces tactic, which one do you use in general?

0

mthn said: I still haven't found which is the best set pieces tactic, which one do you use in general?

I use Azure V3 most of the time but, Blue is also great.

0

abde said: I use Azure V3 most of the time but, Blue is also great.

blue or blue 2 ?

0

mthn said: blue or blue 2 ?
blue

0

It's been 10 months and there are different set pieces now. I am going to upload another one that includes the best performers from the current set and see if it beats my 1-24 best hits.

1

Han106 said: It's been 10 months and there are different set pieces now. I am going to upload another one that includes the best performers from the current set and see if it beats my 1-24 best hits.

Very good friend, I'm waiting

0

Hey, @Mark. Any chance we get Han's last routines tested?

Thank you for all the effort!

0

Speaking of which. I haven't gone through every single routine in here so maybe it's included somewhere. Has Workthespace world cup corner routine been tested? Everyone seems to be using it lately

0

kvasir said: Hey, @Mark. Any chance we get Han's last routines tested?

Thank you for all the effort!



Yarema said: Speaking of which. I haven't gone through every single routine in here so maybe it's included somewhere. Has Workthespace world cup corner routine been tested? Everyone seems to be using it lately

Sorry guys but I don't have the database anymore. Was preparing for FM25 so cleaned up a fair bit of stuff.

2
Create an account or log in to leave a comment