Skip to main content

Welcome To FM-Arena - Football Manager Tactic Testing Site

Football Manager: 19.3 CADONI 4141 v1

Hi,

I have created a tactic based to Mr. Knap, Mr. TFF, Mr. CLASH and Mr. Stephenhk; PI, TI, Set Piece Routines. I have not use it yet; but I have been tested to Mr. L Test League which CA145 was won the league. I hope to test it and see the results from FM-ARENA.

More information can be found here: http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/share-download-fm19-tactics/380586-football-manager-2019-cadoni.html





Thank you a lot!

Best Regards,
Vasileios

reply #1   |   

Hi,

I have not use it yet; but I have been tested to Mr. L Test League which CA145 was won the league. I hope to test it and see the results from FM-ARENA.


Hi,

I've tried testing tactic in Mr. L Test League and I can say that the results were very inaccurate, I mean they were very different from what I got in my normal game save.

I find that the main issue of Mr. L Test League is that when you test tactics then you use Assistant Manager to pick the team for you but it's been proved many times that Assistant Manager is very poor at picking the team, I mean that for one tactic Assistant Manager might pick much better players than for other tactic and because of that issue some poor tactics might get much better result than they deserve comparing with good tactics.

I see that FM-Arena testing league is free from that issue because it uses players that are equally good for doing different tasks.

Also, another issue of Mr. L Test League if some of your key player got a long term injury during testing then you simple don't have an equal substitution for him because all players in the team are different quality but FM-Arena testing league is free from that issue because there are like 3-4 equally good players for every position.

reply #2   |   

Sorry, I forgot to mention that my testing with Mr. L was under FMRTE; which injuries, morale and fitness being freezed. I don't know how AM picks, that's why I am asking here for testing.

Also, this is not an official result from Mr. L team, but with my own experiment.

reply #3   |   

Sorry, I forgot to mention that my testing with Mr. L was under FMRTE; which injuries, morale and fitness being freezed. I don't know how AM picks, that's why I am asking here for testing.

Injuries happen even when you freeze with FMRTE

Of course, you can remove all injuries from your team with FMRTE but to do that you need to manually push some extra buttons… unfortunately "Freezing" thing doesn't do that for you…

reply #6   |   

Injuries happen even when you freeze with FMRTE

Of course, you can remove all injuries from your team with FMRTE but to do that you need to manually push some extra buttons… unfortunately "Freezing" thing doesn't do that for you…

Yeap. Heal Team, Inspire Team and Freeze was selected. I don't know if I need to do something extra on FMRTE. If yes, please feel free to guide me. :)

Best Regards,
V

reply #7   |   

Sorry, I forgot to mention that my testing with Mr. L was under FMRTE; which injuries, morale and fitness being freezed.

Hi,

I've checked your save and found that the Morale and Fitness aren’t "frozen" for the AI teams.

There's no point in testing when you freeze the Morale and Fitness only for your team.


reply #8   |   

Yeap. Heal Team, Inspire Team and Freeze was selected. I don't know if I need to do something extra on FMRTE. If yes, please feel free to guide me. :)

Best Regards,
V

FMRTE can only remove existing injuries but it can't remove future injures that will inevitable happen during testing that's why you need some extra "copied" player(like in FM-Arena testing league) in case of some of your key players get injured.

Check your team and you'll find a lot injured in it.

Also, as Antigo said it doesn't make sense to freeze the morale and fitness only for your team… all teams in the league must be "frozen"

reply #9   |   

Hi,

I've checked your save and found that the Morale and Fitness aren’t "frozen" for the AI teams.

There's no point in testing when you freeze the Morale and Fitness only for your team.

Jez, I am an idiot. I forgot it. Kill me now. Hehe

reply #10   |   

I have started a new one, with all teams being freezed. I will post later the results.

reply #15   |   

Yes sir! https://www.mediafire.com/file/l3v09lqh1913j9c/FM19_CADONI_4141v1_TEST2.fm/file

Hi

I've checked your save and found that "Transfers" can happen in your testing league and that makes the result to be random and inaccurate.

FM-Arena testing league is free of that issue which helps to produce more accurate results.  ;)

X


Also, I found that in your testing league the AI managers aren’t protected from sacking until the end of the testing so the AI Teams might change their tactics during testing which makes the results to be random and inaccurate.

I see that FM-Arena testing league is free of that issue which helps to produce more accurate results.

X


Please, don't take make words as an offense, I just try to give some ideas how you can improve your testing league.  ;)



reply #16   |   

Hi

I've checked your save and found that "Transfers" can happen in your testing league and that makes the result to be random and inaccurate.

FM-Arena testing league is free of that issue which helps to produce more accurate results.  ;)

X


Also, I found that in your testing league the AI managers aren’t protected from sacking until the end of the testing so the AI Teams might change their tactics during testing which makes the results to be random and inaccurate.

I see that FM-Arena testing league is free of that issue which helps to produce more accurate results.

X


Please, don't take make words as an offense, I just try to give some ideas how you can improve your testing league.  ;)

I am not take it as an offense, mate. ;)

I don't know how to stop this issues. Maybe the guys from Mr. L have stop this issues as they started to test tactics. But I am trying a version two of my 4141. CF isn't play well alone. Wingers are far better from WM. Let's see

reply #18   |   

but I have been tested to Mr. L Test League which CA145 was won the league.


Hi

Why do both teams CA120 and CA145 have the same 7300 Reputation in the test league?

It's the lowest reputation between all teams in the league so the AI teams use only their attacking tactics against you and you can't find how your tactic works if the AI teams use their defensive tactics against you. 

reply #19   |   

Don't know. Mr. L is a different test league from FM-ARENA, so. Again, this results is not coming from official Mr. L team; but from my own side. Mr. L has nothing to do with that test.

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.