Recall that 87% for ST is 2.571 and 73% for ST is 6.111, and that positions other than ST appear to be consistently ~1 position lower.
Every position for the Knap 424 formation has been sampled now, and I'm satisfied that the same set of required attributes apply to all outfield positions in the same way.
I've done some readjustments to the weightings.
I've dropped Sterling the equivalent of ~1 position, but this means he should we should expect no worse than ~4 position, yet his average is 5.375 if we give +1 for not being ST. This is the best I've been able to do.
Non-ST positions seem more comparable to ST now (less unexplained position difference), and stamina is now a more reasonable 40 instead of 94 weight - stamina seemed to be the partial cause of Sterling's overrating. Quite a few players have pleasant coincidental changes, such as Maeda going higher and Gyokeres lower, which is more line with the real rankings.
However some changes had to go with it, such as Vlahovic dropping a little below Messi. I figure it's more likely that Sterling should drop 1 position, than Vlahovic should not drop 0.5 position. And given most players seem more to be more accurate now, I'm not too concerned about Vlahovic.
Next step is translating to Genie Scout weights, then I can upload the updated file. Main reason for updated file will be adding the new GK weights of course.
Recall that 87% for ST is 2.571 and 73% for ST is 6.111, and that positions other than ST appear to be consistently ~1 position lower.
Every position for the Knap 424 formation has been sampled now, and I'm satisfied that the same set of required attributes apply to all outfield positions in the same way.
I've done some readjustments to the weightings.
I've dropped Sterling the equivalent of ~1 position, but this means he should we should expect no worse than ~4 position, yet his average is 5.375 if we give +1 for not being ST. This is the best I've been able to do.
Non-ST positions seem more comparable to ST now (less unexplained position difference), and stamina is now a more reasonable 40 instead of 94 weight - stamina seemed to be the partial cause of Sterling's overrating. Quite a few players have pleasant coincidental changes, such as Maeda going higher and Gyokeres lower, which is more line with the real rankings.
However some changes had to go with it, such as Vlahovic dropping a little below Messi. I figure it's more likely that Sterling should drop 1 position, than Vlahovic should not drop 0.5 position. And given most players seem more to be more accurate now, I'm not too concerned about Vlahovic.
Next step is translating to Genie Scout weights, then I can upload the updated file. Main reason for updated file will be adding the new GK weights of course. Expand
86% | Eduardo Camavinga (DM) = 3rd, 5th, 2nd, 3rd, 4th = 3.4 position
73% | Andrian Kraev (DM) = 9th, 8th, 5th, 5th = 6.75 position
Recall that 87% for ST is 2.571 and 73% for ST is 6.111, and that positions other than ST appear to be consistently ~1 position lower.
Every position for the Knap 424 formation has been sampled now, and I'm satisfied that the same set of required attributes apply to all outfield positions in the same way.
I've done some readjustments to the weightings.
I've dropped Sterling the equivalent of ~1 position, but this means he should we should expect no worse than ~4 position, yet his average is 5.375 if we give +1 for not being ST. This is the best I've been able to do.
Non-ST positions seem more comparable to ST now (less unexplained position difference), and stamina is now a more reasonable 40 instead of 94 weight - stamina seemed to be the partial cause of Sterling's overrating. Quite a few players have pleasant coincidental changes, such as Maeda going higher and Gyokeres lower, which is more line with the real rankings.
However some changes had to go with it, such as Vlahovic dropping a little below Messi. I figure it's more likely that Sterling should drop 1 position, than Vlahovic should not drop 0.5 position. And given most players seem more to be more accurate now, I'm not too concerned about Vlahovic.
Next step is translating to Genie Scout weights, then I can upload the updated file. Main reason for updated file will be adding the new GK weights of course.
GeorgeFloydOverdosed said: 86% | Eduardo Camavinga (DM) = 3rd, 5th, 2nd, 3rd, 4th = 3.4 position
73% | Andrian Kraev (DM) = 9th, 8th, 5th, 5th = 6.75 position
Recall that 87% for ST is 2.571 and 73% for ST is 6.111, and that positions other than ST appear to be consistently ~1 position lower.
Every position for the Knap 424 formation has been sampled now, and I'm satisfied that the same set of required attributes apply to all outfield positions in the same way.
I've done some readjustments to the weightings.
I've dropped Sterling the equivalent of ~1 position, but this means he should we should expect no worse than ~4 position, yet his average is 5.375 if we give +1 for not being ST. This is the best I've been able to do.
Non-ST positions seem more comparable to ST now (less unexplained position difference), and stamina is now a more reasonable 40 instead of 94 weight - stamina seemed to be the partial cause of Sterling's overrating. Quite a few players have pleasant coincidental changes, such as Maeda going higher and Gyokeres lower, which is more line with the real rankings.
However some changes had to go with it, such as Vlahovic dropping a little below Messi. I figure it's more likely that Sterling should drop 1 position, than Vlahovic should not drop 0.5 position. And given most players seem more to be more accurate now, I'm not too concerned about Vlahovic.
Next step is translating to Genie Scout weights, then I can upload the updated file. Main reason for updated file will be adding the new GK weights of course.
Can’t wait to see the new weights