In my other thread (FM27 match engine: what we know so far) I've been measuring what things are worth by changing them and counting points. In this one I'm trying to dig into the actual code to answer the why. Like, why is pace and acceleration worth so much, how are they used in the ME, and why other attributes like passing don't seem to matter. I used the an agent to look inside FM27's match engine while it plays real saved matches. It recorded which parts of the engine read each attribute, how often, and at what moment, and then read the busiest parts closely enough to get the formulas they use.
The key learning here is that the engine doesn't play with the numbers on your player's screen. It turns them into match values, rolls dice from them, and spends most of its time on players deciding what to do. The way it uses the dice function is also weird and explains why so many attributes don't make a difference even when they are used by the ME a lot. In fact, it seems (from what I know so far) that pace and acceleration are not called inside the ME more than the other attributes, they are called for the functions that actually matter.
This is still work in progress and some parts I'm more confident than others because we have the actual formulas the game uses and the agent checked it against real matches. Others are our (me and the agent) best reading of what is going on.
I will try to organize everything in comments below so its easier to read and follow.
The key learning here is that the engine doesn't play with the numbers on your player's screen. It turns them into match values, rolls dice from them, and spends most of its time on players deciding what to do. The way it uses the dice function is also weird and explains why so many attributes don't make a difference even when they are used by the ME a lot. In fact, it seems (from what I know so far) that pace and acceleration are not called inside the ME more than the other attributes, they are called for the functions that actually matter.
This is still work in progress and some parts I'm more confident than others because we have the actual formulas the game uses and the agent checked it against real matches. Others are our (me and the agent) best reading of what is going on.
I will try to organize everything in comments below so its easier to read and follow.