Pace and Acceleration are worth about twice as much per point as anything else, and most technical attributes are worth close to nothing inside a match. The table below summarizes the main learnings. It reports the value of one point change in a given attribute (holding the others constant) for the whole squad on expected points (xPts) per game. The report (
Fm-Match-Lab/docs/studies/01-attribute-values.md at main · caiograco289/Fm-Match-Lab) also describes the effect on shots, Xg for and against. This was done on neutral ground,
| Attribute | Per point | Shape from 1 to 20 |
|---|
| Acceleration | +0.068 | 0.082 below 11, 0.049 above |
| Pace | +0.062 | 0.073 below 13, 0.038 above |
| Jumping Reach | +0.035 | 0.019 up to 9, 0.047 above: pays at the top |
| Stamina | +0.034 | steep below 4 (0.092), then 0.026 |
| Strength | +0.009 in xPts, but about +0.036 in real points | works through goals, not chances (see FAQ) |
| Anticipation | +0.024 | straight line |
| Work Rate | +0.022 | a floor: 1 costs half a point a game, 3-6 a little, 9-20 nothing |
| Concentration | +0.021 | straight line |
| Balance | +0.017 | straight line |
| Dribbling | +0.017 | straight line |
| Decisions | +0.005 | about nothing at every level |
| Passing | +0.003 | about nothing at every level, even at 1 |
| Finishing | 0.000 in xPts | converts chances: +0.3 goals a game from 1 to 20 |
Not in the table, from the +5 tests on real matches: Composure and Vision show a little; Technique, First Touch, Crossing, Off the Ball, Tackling, Marking and Positioning show nothing clear; Natural Fitness is exactly zero inside a match.
I also did a bunch of additional tests that are interesting. Let me try to summarize them in a questions and answer format:
Is every point worth the same? Is 16 to 20 bigger than 8 to 12?
For most attributes, yes, each point is worth about the same, with no threshold. Four exceptions: Pace and Acceleration are worth more below about 12 than above. Jumping Reach is the opposite, flat up to 9 and then the steepest gain of any attribute (12 to 18 is worth +0.34 a game). Work Rate only hurts below about 9. Stamina hurts most below 4. There are reported in
study 12
Do physical attributes only win because tests use meta tactics?
No. Physical +5 (Pace, Acceleration, Stamina, Work Rate, Aggression) is worth +0.38 to +0.48 a game under all five styles tested, possession styles included. Passing attributes help direct styles (Direct Counter-Attack +0.15, Gegenpress +0.11) and do nothing for Tiki-Taka or Control Possession, whose players already complete 90-92% of passes. Stamina pays at every intensity, most with a high press. These are reported in
study 9
Do attributes combine, so a group is worth more than its parts?
No. Groups of four (playmaking, ball carrying, defending, aerial) raised together are worth exactly what their members are worth one at a time. Each group's value comes from one or two members: Jumping Reach is the whole aerial group, Anticipation the whole defending group. These are in
study 10
Are weights different by position? Is Pace worth more for a winger than a midfielder?
I couldn't find any statistical differences. Giving +5 to one pair of players at a time (centre-backs, full-backs, DMs, wide AMs, strikers) gives about 0.03-0.06 a game for all positions. There are some small differences but statistically it could be just from chance. I didn't test all attributes and this is something I want to revisit at some point, but so far the conclusion is that there are no clear differences. These are reported in
study 13
Is one player worth one-eleventh of the whole team?
This surprised me and the answer is not always. The results show that +5 Jumping Reach on just three players gives two-thirds of the whole team's gain. The first players you improve seems to matter most. These are reported in
study 13.
Do attribute values change for a strong or weak team?
It doesn't seem so (at least among premier league level teams). The ranking is the same for top, middle and bottom sides, favourite or underdog (rank correlation 0.84). An underdog may gain a little less overall, mostly at the back, but that this is not statistically different. These are reported in
study 14
Why do Strength and Finishing look weak in xG-based tables?
It seems the answer is that they act on conversion, which xG don't measure. From 1 to 20, Strength adds 0.5 goals a game above xG and +0.69 real points. It also hurt a lot below 6. Finishing adds about 0.3 goals. These are reported in
study 12
Which hidden attributes matter? Is it only Consistency?
It doesn't seem so. Consistency matters across matches in a way that is not capture by the ME. In the ME, it barely matters and isn't even read (need to understand why) in many matches. Pressure is the one with a clear effect. A a squad at Pressure 1 loses 0.15 a game (about 6 points a season). Important Matches doesn't seem to be worth more on European games. Dirtiness and Temperament change cards but not results. These are reported on
study 11
Does Current Ability play a role in the match?
No. With every attribute fixed, a squad at CA 40 does as well as one at CA 200, and Passing or Decisions +5 is worth the same at CA 60 as at 180. CA is read during the match, but it doesn't seem to change chances or results. Better players matter through their attributes. These are reported in
study 20
What about goalkeepers?
This surprised me and I think I need to revist this since it goes against what we previously knew. In my tests, no single goalkeeper attribute +5 has a clear effect alone (Positioning and Concentration lead). All of them +5 together raise the save rate from 75% to 80%, about +0.26 points a game. The keeper's position rating matters far more: at 10 his save rate drops to 60%, conceding 0.7 more goals a game. xG-based tables miss keepers entirely, because saves change goals, not xG. These are reported in s
tudy 21
Why do these numbers differ from HarvestGreen's?
As far as I know we use the same engine (lqf0624's tool), with different setups. The order at the top agrees. On the Windows tool's sample match with everyone at 12, most effects shrink to about 40% of their size on real matches and some vanish. I think it has to do with the type of match it was trained on. I did most of my simulations on real matches (loaded from my save) and then modified. On these real matches, even levelled to 12, mental attributes like Anticipation and Concentration clearly count. These are reported in
study 2
There are a lot of caveats and different ways to have done these. So let me know if you spot any issues or any follow ups that might be useful.