What I've learned about tactical effectiveness

caiograco

Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2026
Messages
63
Reaction score
53
This is such a complicated topic. I've run a bunch of experiments on it using the match engine outside the game, and I've also decompiled the match engine into its own functions and pieces. Below is my best attempt to summarize everything (yes, with the help of AI. I went back and forth with it to get the clearest summary I could, so its not slop, and the result is clearer than what I would have written alone). Let me know if anything is confusing and we can chat about it. Hopefully it's useful for anyone building training plans, or anyone who just wants to know how this works.

TL;DR:​

Each player has eight tactical-area values (0-100), shown as the pies on the Tactical Familiarity screen. Only two really matter for results: chance creation and pressing intensity. Out-of-possession shape matters about half as much; the other five barely matter. The headline numbers (overall effectiveness, buy-in, next match info) have almost no effect on results. "Per season" means 38 matches.

What to do​

  • Get chance creation and pressing intensity above 50 for every regular starter (a pie of 6+ segments). Below 41 instead of just above 50 costs about 4-5 points a season per area. Pushing on towards 9-10 segments adds only 1-2 more.
  • Then out-of-possession shape. Leave the other five to match play.
  • Check players, not the team pie. One starter at 30 loses while a teammate at 90 gains, and the team pie hides it. New signings and players in new positions are usually the low ones; training is the quickest fix for them.
  • Bands, not points. A change matters only when it crosses a band (16, 34, 41, 51, 67, 81, 91). 70 to 78 changes nothing; 48 to 52 does.
  • Simple tactics help everyone. Every 10 points of complexity costs 2.5 points in every area for every player.
  • Don't tweak settings right before a match. Each notch away from what the team knows costs about 3 points in that area until they've played it.

Quick glossary​

  • Area value: a player's familiarity with one tactical area, 0-100. A pie has 10 segments of 10 points.
  • Dice: every few seconds the engine rolls a random number for each mental and technical attribute. A player with 15 Anticipation plays, in each moment, like whatever he just rolled. Familiarity makes some rolls bigger or smaller.
  • Band: values are grouped (below 16, 16-33, 34-40, 41-50, 51-66, 67-80, 81-90, 91-100). Within a band the effect is the same.
  • Match exposure: how used the team is to the exact settings you play, built up by playing them.
  • Study: one of my simulation experiments, running the match engine thousands of times with settings I control.

1. What the screen shows​

"Checked" = my formula matches the game's own numbers; "code" = read from the decompiled engine.

Panel itemWhat it isHow sure
Tactical Areas piesArea values, 0-100. In Player View a player's pie is his average of all eight areasChecked (PSV match, 11 players)
Player Tactical AbilityFrom his mental attributes (2.1)Checked, exact
Tactical ComplexityThree complexity numbers (2.4)Checked (order), code
Capability, Role SuitabilityPosition rating and role fit; only feeds overallCode
Player Buy-InCoaching, relationships, head-coach tendenciesChecked (order)
Next Match InfoOpposition report and player knowledgeChecked (order)
Overall Effectiveness0.5 × average of the eight areas + 0.25 × buy-in + 0.15 × next match + 0.1 × player abilityChecked, exact
The pies are the result, not the training input: they already include tactical ability, exposure, complexity and training.

2. What goes into an area value​

In plain words: up to 25 points from the player's mental attributes, up to 30 from playing these settings, up to 25 for a simple tactic, and up to 60 from training. Anything above 100 is cut off.

area value = round(0.25 × tactical ability + 0.3 × exposure + 0.25 × (100 − complexity)) + round(0.6 × training), kept between 0 and 100 (checked exactly on 20,000 records)
2.1 Tactical ability. The middle value of Anticipation, Decisions, Composure, Concentration and Versatility, converted to 0-100: (middle − 1) × 100/19. A middle value of 14 gives 68, i.e. 17 points in every area.

2.2 Match exposure. The team remembers how familiar it is with every setting it has used in each area. Exposure = familiarity with the nearest known setting, minus 10 per notch away from it. Fully used to a setting (99) and you move it one notch: about 89, so the area loses about 3 points. In- and out-of-possession shape come from the two formations. In the PSV match, established starters had 99 but newer players 0-26, costing them up to 30 points in every area.

2.3 Training. A training number per area (12-68 in the PSV line-up). Sessions raise it; untrained areas fade. Every 10 training points add 6 to the area. How sessions turn into this number is outside the match engine and not decoded yet.

2.4 Complexity. 60% team part + 30% instructions-and-roles part (instructions switched on, plus the player's role and duty) + 10% formation part (0 in all my cases). The PSV tactic's team part was 78 (a Chelsea tactic I tested: 4). Complexity 78 adds only 5.5 points instead of up to 25: about 20 points lost in every area.

2.5 Two PSV starters, same area:

Starter 1Starter 2
Tactical ability68 → 1753 → 13.25
Exposure99 → 29.70 → 0
Complexity70 → 7.577 → 5.75
Base (rounded)5419
Training39 → 2320 → 12
Area value7731
Both match the game's records. Most of the gap is exposure: Starter 2 was new to the tactic.

3. What the values do in a match​

Each die is rolled between 0 and about the attribute + 2, re-rolled for the team about every 24 seconds of match time. Play reads the die, not the attribute. After each roll, area values stretch or shrink two dice:

Area value<1616-3334-4041-5051-6667-8081-9091-100
Die ×0.500.750.851.001.151.301.451.60
The change is capped at 5 either way, roughly 2-3 attribute points on the 1-20 scale. At ×1.30 about half of all rolls already hit the cap, so going above about 70 adds little, while dropping below 41 starts taking points away.

AreaDice it scales
Chance creationAnticipation, Off the Ball
Pressing intensityAnticipation, Tackling
Out-of-possession shapeConcentration, Marking
Passing styleDecisions, Composure
Pressing trapDecisions, Positioning
Build-upTechnique, Vision
In-possession shapeFirst Touch, team cohesion
Line of engagementWork Rate, Aggression
The headline numbers scale other dice (overall: a morale die on dribbles and placed shots; buy-in: Sportsmanship, Teamwork, Professionalism; next match: Pressure). In 80,000 simulated matches none had a reliable effect on results.

4. What each area is worth​

In 80,000 simulated matches I set one area to a chosen value for every player at once, with the other areas random, and measured points against a baseline of 45 (where dice are unchanged). Points per season, accurate to about ±1.

Area value825374558738595
Chance creation−3.6−3.2−2.50+2.1+2.4+2.9+3.2
Pressing intensity−3.3−3.0−2.70+1.8+2.8+3.1+3.5
Out-of-possession shape−2.3−1.7−1.20+0.2+0.8+1.3+0.9
Build-up−0.5+0.1−0.30+0.6+1.2+1.0+1.2
Passing style−0.8−0.5−0.30+0.3+0.4+0.5+0.7
In-possession shape−0.6−0.2−0.20+0.3+0.3+0.7+0.5
Pressing trap−0.3−0.1−0.30+0.2+0.3+0.3+0.1
Line of engagement−1.1+0.2−0.20−0.4−0.6−0.8−0.5

Why this order? An area matters as much as the attributes behind its dice. Anticipation is the only one with a large effect on its own, and it sits under two areas. Concentration comes next; the rest are worth little.
 
Last edited:
So wen can really say now that the impact of this is not so strong.
I mean... getting the training correct for the top 2 areas is worth 3-6 points a season, which could decide a championship or a place in the european leagues. But yeah, you are better off focusing on hiring the best players you can.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZaZ
So this then, right? That's going in every week in my save and I will see how it does

1794868675176.webp
 
So this then, right? That's going in every week in my save and I will see how it does

View attachment 1075
I think that is probably what will end up being the meta. But we need more testing. What I showed is what influences match results, but it doesn't say how training influences the 8 tactical areas and what are the tradeoffs. I know you and other folks are looking into that, so we need to combine both results, which I think will look something like what you have.
 
Back
Top