New to the forum so apologies if I am violating any rules.
Mark said: I flick between my own and ykykyky and think they are still both working well. Expand
I want your input in the comparison between Mark's and ykykyky ratings for DRL's. In particular for the following right backs. 24-year old Carmona and 19 year old wonderkid Roscio.
Carmona is better on the physical attributes which weight more in the ratings and slightly worse in the technical attributes which do not weight that much.
For the mental attributes, Mark's rating values Decisions and Positioning the most on which Roscio is better. The ykykyky rating values Off the Ball and Work Rate more on which Carmona is better.
The ratings (if I computed them correctly) are as follows: Game CA: Roscio 152, Carmona 151 Mark's rating converted to CA: Carmona 158.3, Roscio 158.1 ykykyky rating converted to CA: Carmona 153.8, Roscio 140 ykykyky -25 for under 50: Carmona: 167.3, Roscio 143.9
Mark said: I flick between my own and ykykyky and think they are still both working well.
I want your input in the comparison between Mark's and ykykyky ratings for DRL's. In particular for the following right backs. 24-year old Carmona and 19 year old wonderkid Roscio.
Carmona is better on the physical attributes which weight more in the ratings and slightly worse in the technical attributes which do not weight that much.
For the mental attributes, Mark's rating values Decisions and Positioning the most on which Roscio is better. The ykykyky rating values Off the Ball and Work Rate more on which Carmona is better.
The ratings (if I computed them correctly) are as follows:
Game CA: Roscio 152, Carmona 151
Mark's rating converted to CA: Carmona 158.3, Roscio 158.1
ykykyky rating converted to CA: Carmona 153.8, Roscio 140
ykykyky -25 for under 50: Carmona: 167.3, Roscio 143.9