Gerrard
Waqasnufc said: What tactic you recommend? I'm currently using a 424 attacking one but I need a formation or tactic that still attacks and on low tempo still attacks with controlled against the big teams what would you reccomend on this?

These concede less
BASED ON PERFECT STRANGERS 42112 WIWB P107 EC FA
4213 SHORT PASSING HIGH TEMPO
W TO PF
BASED ON PERFECT STRANGERS 42112 WIWB P107 EC FA
4213 SHORT PASSING HIGH TEMPO
IF TO CF
Waqasnufc said: Can I keep this on postive or balanced to control away tough games? Also take off counter press and  lower the tempo down?

I seldom change tempo but the rest are progressive tweaks towards a SUS. What you use depends on the match and stage of the match.
Y15ARG said: Is the only change here the IWBa to IWBs or is there anything else?

Usually SP means I've used the short passing tweak
DM on defend
Waqasnufc said: As I'm using the 424 main and best one on this site. I have full backs on attack. I just want a 424 tactic that's controls and still attacks I feel like the caution and defensive approach is inviting pressure any other ideas mate

Try balanced or control tweaks, can also use a DMD
Waqasnufc said: 433 doesn't seem effective as the 424 but I need a defensive tactic for the 424 can you help?

CONTROL TACTIC

Remove Counter Press and/or Counter

For a SUS these are ideas to use.
Remove counter press counter

Stop WB runs by going to defend or no nonsense FB

Change mentality cautious/Defensive

full SUS would be to regroup and hold shape
Waqasnufc said: What's best solution for a red card? Drop to postive and play 2dms?

USE 1 MC, Can drop mentality if required
Waqasnufc said: Can I take invite crosses off as I have lots of small full backs?

Depends on CBs
Waqasnufc said: Would you recommend am or yourself?

I don't recommend AM but I do not test training.
4213 SHORT PASSING HIGH TEMPO
BASED ON PERFECT STRANGERS 42112 WIWB P107 EC FA
4213 SHORT PASSING HIGH TEMPO
IF TO CF
Waqasnufc said: Does it matter about stars? Cus this formation rocks

Probably need to rad all the attribute information such as
https://fm-arena.com/thread/13685-current-24-4-latest-version-full-attribute-test-52000-match-samples/
Waqasnufc said: Can you reccomend me a VOL then can't find any good ones and a winger on the left mid?

I only use original squads, so just make players fit. Just look by position and ignore roles.
As long as ME 24.2 I would try it
Waqasnufc said: Can it be a CM instead of VOL? And not that many wingers on the left who you reccomend?

Would be a different tactic. Most WBs or IFs can play winger position and become more accomplished over a season
Waqasnufc said: Do you reccomend any training on this tactic I haven't done anything so far on that if there is can you send me

I just use AM
Waqasnufc said: But shall I keep rest team instructions same?

The tactics on tab have already been lowered if necessary. Any other tactics should work on a dropped mentality apart from 424s that can stay the same. All other instructions can stay the same.