I don't think it is necessary to credit the "original" tactic creator, that should be left optional to the "new/improved" tactic creator. If someone takes a tactic and makes it better, what even is the point to credit the original tactic? I won't go there (and neither would most casual FM players) to get the original tactic which performs worse than the new tactic made by the "new" creator. If someone's edited tactic is better than the original then that's it. Want to be recognized as the X tactic creator? Then improve that tactic so nobody can edit and make it better.
( Thank god there is no downvote button on FM-Arena =]] )
ZaZ said: Thank you for testing. Fire is just a new name for Blue in FM23. It is the same tactic, just converted to the new match engine.
For everyone else waiting, remember we are here just to have fun. I am checking some different instructions, and it's pretty hard to measure with precision when you don't have the editor to make testing more stable. One thing is to test instructions individually, another thing completely different is to test the synergy between two or more instructions. It takes time, even more when I can't make a special league to test yet.
Anyway, here is the best I came up to now. I am still trying to find some improvements before I start testing different formations and roles. Keep in mind that the difference is not very high, and might even be non-existent after I test with more precision, but right now, my tests say there is a difference statistically significant. Let me know how it works for you! Expand
You might want to look into FM Genie Scout tool, to me, is much better than the editor. Shows so much more data than the editor. Unfortunately, it cannot edit stuff tho.
Quick question. Do you guys train two versions of this tactic on both Attacking and Defensive mentalities with both Short and Direct passing in order to increase familiarity?
This tactic on Defensive mentality with Slightly More Direct or More Direct passing slaps. I brought a small Romanian team (Dinamo 1948) to the UCL league (former groups) in season 2.
P.S. It looks like in FM23 you really have to manage "hard tackles", I mean you can't have it "On" all the time and you should constantly make a decision whether using it or not. Expand
Thanks. I will try to remove it. In FM22 it wasn't this bad.
If someone takes a tactic and makes it better, what even is the point to credit the original tactic?
I won't go there (and neither would most casual FM players) to get the original tactic which performs worse than the new tactic made by the "new" creator.
If someone's edited tactic is better than the original then that's it.
Want to be recognized as the X tactic creator? Then improve that tactic so nobody can edit and make it better.
( Thank god there is no downvote button on FM-Arena =]] )
For everyone else waiting, remember we are here just to have fun. I am checking some different instructions, and it's pretty hard to measure with precision when you don't have the editor to make testing more stable. One thing is to test instructions individually, another thing completely different is to test the synergy between two or more instructions. It takes time, even more when I can't make a special league to test yet.
Anyway, here is the best I came up to now. I am still trying to find some improvements before I start testing different formations and roles. Keep in mind that the difference is not very high, and might even be non-existent after I test with more precision, but right now, my tests say there is a difference statistically significant. Let me know how it works for you!
You might want to look into FM Genie Scout tool, to me, is much better than the editor.
Shows so much more data than the editor. Unfortunately, it cannot edit stuff tho.
Do you guys train two versions of this tactic on both Attacking and Defensive mentalities with both Short and Direct passing in order to increase familiarity?
I brought a small Romanian team (Dinamo 1948) to the UCL league (former groups) in season 2.
Works well against bigger teams.
Look at these posts:
https://fm-arena.com/thread/2681-insane-amount-of-yellow-and-red-card-in-fm23/
https://fm-arena.com/find-comment/14536/
P.S. It looks like in FM23 you really have to manage "hard tackles", I mean you can't have it "On" all the time and you should constantly make a decision whether using it or not.
Thanks. I will try to remove it. In FM22 it wasn't this bad.