Cherknam
Same as Osmo RPM XI except:

IF instead of W
RGA instead of VOL
FB instead of IWB
Same as '42112 Asabiyyah' except IF changed to AM and moved to AMCL.
Similar to '42112 Asabiyyah':

- VOL changed to AM and moved to AMCR
- FB no longer aiming crosses at near post
Now focussing play down both the left and the right.
Adaptation of 'Osmo RPM XI':

- AF moved from left striker to right striker
- AM changed into IF and moved from AMCL to AML
- Now focussing play down the right, as opposed to down the left
Winger on attack duty in AMR.
Trequartista instead of W.
Winger on attack duty, moved to AMR.
'Close down more' added to all possible.
'Take more risks' removed from AF and VOL
RGA instead of RPM
A Smile said: First of all, thank you for your hard work. However, I don't think RNG is any different, this can be seen by the upper and lower limits of the score presented, still generally between 2 and 3, while the more difficult score and the number of tests also offset each other's bonus. There were also nearly identical tactical test results, such as the Problem Solvin V18 and the 424 Classic CBP87 v1.8.
RNG is closely related to the number of test venues, and the effectiveness of these three tactical test reforms is only regressive in terms of RNG. I think the accuracy of the test results still needs more test matches to improve, and the tactics with higher scores need to unify the test matches, whether it is 4800 or 9600. Even that doesn't really tell the difference between two nearly identical tactics.


Perhaps they haven't updated the upper and lower limits yet. I doubt they would've restarted if the RNG wasn't actually reduced by the new testing league.



dzek said: Results will be the same regardless of the difficulty and I think every time we (re)test them we will have a different "winner" because all the tactics are close.

Just wondering if FM-Arena introduces the 4222 and 5221 formations to the AI teams to see if there is any change in the results.


I'm not sure if results would be the same regardless of difficulty. Are some tactics not better against harder teams than they are against weaker teams, relative to other tactics?
callum1244 said: Player instructions?
- Removed 'take more risks' from AF and VOL
- Added 'take more risks' and 'more direct passing' to IWB
- Added 'cross from byline' and 'take more risks' to W
- Removed ' cross from byline' and 'aim crosses at near post' from FB
- Added 'Dribble more', 'Shoot less often' and 'Run wide with ball' to FB
- Removed overlap and underlap
- Attacking mentality
- Removed 'run wide with ball', 'dribble more' and 'shoot less often' from FB
- Added 'cross from byline' and 'aim crosses at near post' to FB
- 'Take more risks' and 'more direct passing' added to IWB
- 'Take more risks' removed from AF and VOL
- 'Hold up ball' removed from AM
- 'Cross from byline' and 'take more risks' added to W
- 'Take more risks' and 'more direct passing' added to IWB
- 'Take more risks' removed from AF and VOL
RGA instead of RPM.