Birmingham 4-3-3 REV2 - 190-match local test - FM27 27.1.0

Patch 27.1.0

The results are valid for FM Patch 27.1.0
Results PLD PTS GD GF GA xGF xGA xGD
Overall 1,350 47 / 114 -7 52 59 49 54 -5
Home 675 26 / 57 0 28 28
Away 675 21 / 57 -8 24 32

Tactic info

Tactic info

5310honey

New member
Joined
Nov 15, 2026
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Birmingham 4-3-3 REV2 — FM27 27.1.0

This is REV2 of my previously shared Birmingham 4-3-3, not the original 27.0.1 file. The REV2 .fmf is attached for sharing/testing.
Original thread: Birmingham 4-3-3 FM27 27.0.1 Testing Request

Concept
4-1-2-3 in possession, 4-1-4-1 out of possession. The deep-lying forward links play; a right wide playmaker and left inverted winger combine with a midfield playmaker and a channel midfielder/mezzala. The right inverted full-back supports central circulation. Out of possession, the striker tracks back and the wide midfielders help protect the flanks. Short passing, low tempo and counter-pressing are part of the approach. All outfield players use shoot-less-often to encourage combinations and better shot selection; this is an intention, not proof of optimality.

190-match independent LOCAL test — not an official FM-Arena score
FM27 Tactics Lab v1118.1; native/save build 27.1.0+2505117; snapshot date 2027-03-06.
Current custom-youngster XI and attributes frozen, no projected growth. Starting XI mean CA 135.64; opponent starting XI mean CA 148.56 (200 scale). These are custom legend-inspired players with unusual attribute distributions/traits: low mean CA does not make this a normal weak-team benchmark.
19 current-save EPL opponents, home and away, five seeds (31001–31005): 38 matches per seed, 190 total. Current-save opponent players and manager-preference tactical presets, not exact match-day AI. Fulham had no valid manager contract and could not be recovered; Coventry was included, so Birmingham takes Fulham's place in this hypothetical slate.
Condition/sharpness 100%, fatigue 0, morale 20/20, team cohesion 80, club cohesion 100, league match importance 13. No carry-over injuries, fatigue, suspensions, transfers or growth.

Results (each slate = 38 matches)
1: 14W 10D 14L | 52 points | 47–47 goals | xG/match 1.42–1.44
2: 13W 6D 19L | 45 points | 59–64 goals | xG/match 1.56–1.49
3: 17W 5D 16L | 56 points | 67–55 goals | xG/match 1.62–1.39
4: 16W 9D 13L | 57 points | 53–53 goals | xG/match 1.55–1.39
5: 19W 7D 12L | 64 points | 70–53 goals | xG/match 1.56–1.70
Overall: 79W 37D 74L, win rate 41.58%, 296 GF / 272 GA.
Per match: GF 1.558 / GA 1.432; xGF 1.545 / xGA 1.480.
Mean 38-match points: 54.8. These are five independent slates, not five consecutive seasons. No league ranking or player match ratings were produced.

Home (95): 52W 19D 24L | 183–103 goals | xG/match 1.776–1.181.
Away (95): 27W 18D 50L | 113–169 goals | xG/match 1.314–1.779.
All 190 completed without failures; native scenario/profile/tactic bindings and scorer/card totals checked against logs.

Starting-XI player totals: goals / assists (190 games)
GK Neuer 0/0; RB Puyol 4/6; RCB Ferdinand 3/4; LCB Nesta 1/3; LB Roberto Carlos 6/26; DM Busquets 5/8; LCM Modric 24/19; RCM Gerrard 64/41; RW Messi 46/50; LW Ronaldinho 51/51; ST Oh 88/51.
The custom names do not imply real-life prime attributes.

The results summary image is attached; the conditions, 38-match aggregates and XI totals are listed above. This forum does not accept ZIP/CSV attachments. No save file is included.
I would appreciate independent testing and feedback, especially on away defensive stability and preserving the DLF/wing/midfield combinations. If you try it, please mention your club, patch and whether you changed any roles.
REV2_190match_summary.webp


Detailed data download
The 190-match scores/xG, player G/A/cards, opponent CA and methodology ZIP are attached to my companion FMKorea post: https://www.fmkorea.com/10581429429
 

FM tactic for testing FM tactic locked

  • Birmingham 4-3-3 REV2 - 190-match local test - FM27 27.1.0.fmf
    1.2 KB · Views: 37
Back
Top