LightningFlik
New member
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2026
- Messages
- 28
- Reaction score
- 18
Youth intake stuff
Strap in.
tl;dr
I spent a long time pulling apart FM24's game code to trace exactly how youth intakes are made. I then checked it against a real save (Aston Villa) by watching the preview arrive in December and the intake land on 15 March. Everything below matches what the game actually did. Where a number is an example, it uses Villa's values from that save.
A few caveats:
AI clubs don't get anything in December. Their whole intake is generated from scratch on their intake day.
Part 2: Preview day — creating the players
On preview day the game builds a "blueprint" for each incoming player. A blueprint contains:
How many players
The number depends on how short of players your nation is. The game compares the number of players it wants in the nation with how many it has.
The hidden quality tier
Each regular player rolls a tier. This is the most important hidden number in the whole process.
Some adjustments apply:
Villa's 16 were: 4 Good, 4 Standard, 3 Weak and 5 gap-fillers.
Part 3: The preview itself
To fill in the preview, the game takes each blueprint and makes a temporary practice copy of the player. It then runs the full intake-day CA and PA generation on that copy (Parts 4–6). Your HoYD rates each practice player. The real CA and PA are rolled again on intake day.
This is the key point: the preview grades a practice roll from the same dice the real players will use. It is a good guide to the odds, not a promise.
Step 1: Your club's benchmark
The game works out a benchmark (B) from your senior squad:
A stronger first team means a higher bar for youngsters to clear.
Step 2: Judge each practice player
The HoYD gives each practice player a rating R on the 0–200 scale. Each player is then labelled:
Step 3: Grades per position group
Players are grouped by their natural position: GK, full-backs, centre-backs, DM, central mids, wide mids, AMC, wingers, strikers and wing-backs. For each group:
A group with no players shows "–".
Step 4: The star rating
Take the average R of your top 6 practice players and call it T. Then:
Next, a little HoYD noise is added. It depends on the HoYD's judging ability (1–20):
A HoYD with better judging gives you a more accurate preview. Nothing I traced suggests he changes the players themselves.
Strap in.
tl;dr
- Your youth intake players are created on preview day. Their names, ages, nationalities, positions and a hidden "quality tier" are decided then and never change.
- Their CA and PA are not decided until intake day. The preview is the Head of Youth Development judging a practice roll of each player, not the real thing.
- PA is driven mostly by junior coaching and your nation's youth rating, with youth facilities a distant third. Training facilities play no part.
- A hidden nation-wide PA quota then moves players up or down. In England it pushes many players up, but it's first come, first served: once the country's quota for a PA band is used up, later clubs miss out.
- CA is mostly set at roughly 40–55 % of the final PA, adjusted for age.
I spent a long time pulling apart FM24's game code to trace exactly how youth intakes are made. I then checked it against a real save (Aston Villa) by watching the preview arrive in December and the intake land on 15 March. Everything below matches what the game actually did. Where a number is an example, it uses Villa's values from that save.
A few caveats:
- This is FM24. Other versions may differ.
- I've described the rules that apply in a normal save at a club in a big footballing nation. There are a handful of special cases for particular countries, clubs and US academy leagues that I mostly skip (because I've been at this for ages).
- Anything random is a dice roll. When I say "1 in 20", that's the actual roll in the code.
| When | What happens |
| 93 days before your nation's intake window opens, at 09:00 (mid-December for England) | The game creates every youth player for clubs with a human manager, and sends you the Youth Intake Preview |
| The intake window (mid-March for England, spread over several days) | Each club in the nation gets its own day. On your day, the players created in December become real players and their CA and PA are rolled. |
| End of the window | Clean-up, and the game tops up the pool of unattached youngsters. |
AI clubs don't get anything in December. Their whole intake is generated from scratch on their intake day.
Part 2: Preview day — creating the players
On preview day the game builds a "blueprint" for each incoming player. A blueprint contains:
- name, nationality (and any second nationality), place of birth and date of birth;
- positions (which positions they're natural in);
- a hidden quality tier.
How many players
The number depends on how short of players your nation is. The game compares the number of players it wants in the nation with how many it has.
- England in my save wanted 4,860 and had 4,539, so it was 321 short. A gap that big gives league clubs 14–16 players.
- A smaller gap (150–299 short) gives 10–12, and smaller still gives fewer.
- Reserve and affiliate teams get 3–6. Top-division clubs always get at least 7.
The hidden quality tier
Each regular player rolls a tier. This is the most important hidden number in the whole process.
| Chance | What it means later | |
| Elite | 0.5% | Best PA odds, best CA range, and it skips the quota (see Part 5) |
| Good | 18% | Strong PA odds |
| Standard | 54% | Middling PA odds |
| Weak | 27.5 | Poor PA odds |
| Gap-filler | (see below) | Fills empty positions; PA kept low |
Some adjustments apply:
- In lower leagues, Elite and Good players can be swapped to Standard.
- At low-reputation clubs, Weak players have a 1 in 3 chance of becoming Standard.
Villa's 16 were: 4 Good, 4 Standard, 3 Weak and 5 gap-fillers.
Part 3: The preview itself
To fill in the preview, the game takes each blueprint and makes a temporary practice copy of the player. It then runs the full intake-day CA and PA generation on that copy (Parts 4–6). Your HoYD rates each practice player. The real CA and PA are rolled again on intake day.
This is the key point: the preview grades a practice roll from the same dice the real players will use. It is a good guide to the odds, not a promise.
Step 1: Your club's benchmark
The game works out a benchmark (B) from your senior squad:
B = average over your best 13 players of (CA + PA) / 2A stronger first team means a higher bar for youngsters to clear.
Step 2: Judge each practice player
The HoYD gives each practice player a rating R on the 0–200 scale. Each player is then labelled:
- Good if
R > 159, or ifR ≥ B × g, whereg = 1.4 − 0.4 × (B − 50) / 110, kept between 1.0 and 1.4. - Poor if
R < B × p, wherep = 1.0 − 0.2 × (B − 50) / 110, kept between 0.8 and 1.0. - Average otherwise.
Example. With a benchmark of B = 120:
With a weaker squad (B = 80), the bars are 1.29 × 80 ≈ 103 for "good" and 0.95 × 80 = 76 for "poor". In proportion to the squad, the bar for "good" is higher at a smaller club. In absolute terms it's far lower.
- g = 1.4 − 0.4 × 70/110 ≈ 1.15, so a player needs R ≥ 138 to be "good"
- p = 1.0 − 0.2 × 70/110 ≈ 0.87, so R < 105 is "poor".
Step 3: Grades per position group
Players are grouped by their natural position: GK, full-backs, centre-backs, DM, central mids, wide mids, AMC, wingers, strikers and wing-backs. For each group:
score = 4 × (good players) + (average players) − (poor players), kept between −4 and +4| Score | −4, −3 | −2, −1 | 0 | 1, 2 | 3 | 4 |
| Grade | F | E | D | C | B | A |
A group with no players shows "–".
Examples.
- Full-backs with one good and two average players: 4 + 2 = 6, capped at 4 → A.
- A single good player on his own also gets an A.
- Centre-backs with one average and one poor player: 1 − 1 = 0 → D.
- A lone poor goalkeeper: −1 → E.
Step 4: The star rating
Take the average R of your top 6 practice players and call it T. Then:
Code:
if T > B: rating = 20 (5 stars)
else: rating = 11 + 36 × (min(T/B, 1) − 0.75) (T/B no lower than 0.75)
stars = (rating − 10) / 2
Next, a little HoYD noise is added. It depends on the HoYD's judging ability (1–20):
| HoYD judging | Noise on the rating | Noise on the player count |
| 16–20 | none | exact |
| 6–15 | ±1 (half a star) | ±1 |
| 1–5 | ±2 (one star) | ±2 |
Example.** B = 120 and the top six average T = 110:
If the top six averaged above 120, you'd see **5 stars** before any noise.
- T/B = 0.917, so rating = 11 + 36 × 0.167 = 17, which is 3½ stars.
- A HoYD with judging 10 could show 3, 3½ or 4 stars.
A HoYD with better judging gives you a more accurate preview. Nothing I traced suggests he changes the players themselves.