Test tactics, compare results and discuss Football Manager together.
www.fm-helper.de
Assessment
From the test program
Points/game (team-balanced) 1.740 Each team weighted equally
Goal difference/game (team-balanced) +0.597 per game
Comparison with the field
Average of 5 other tested tactics with at least 30 games; each tactic counts once.
Strength: Against weaker opponents: 2.17 points/game (field 1.99; better than 100% of the other tactics)
Strength: Attack: 2.35 goals/game (field 1.79; better than 100% of the other tactics)
Weakness: Defense: 1.75 goals conceded/game (field 1.57; worse than 80% of the other tactics)
Notable findings
Clearly dependent on squad quality Top teams 2.16 · Mid-table 1.81 · Relegation 1.26 points per game. The gap between Top teams and Relegation is 0.90 points per game; output drops markedly with weaker squads.
Converts chances above average 2.35 goals from 2.14 xG per game (+0.20 per game). The tactic gets more from its chances than expected.
Strengths
Overall: Chance advantage xG difference +0.414 per game at 1.740 points per game. (1140 Games)
Against equal opponents: Chance advantage xG difference +0.352 per game at 1.708 points per game. (120 Games)
Against weaker opponents: Chance advantage xG difference +0.839 per game at 2.165 points per game. (540 Games)
Weaknesses
Relative decline away For the same team-opponent pairs: home 1.911, away 1.570 points per game (57 pairs, each pair weighted equally). This is a relative difference, not proof of its cause. (1140 Games)
Notes
Pressing susceptibility, required player pace or role demands are not explained by these result data alone.