Gianaa9 said: Honestly from my point of view it isn't about finding who is creating the best tactic, but finding the tactic. ... i can't see it as a competition, we're just working together trying to improve more and more. Expand
Well said. It would be nice some people stopped behaving like they are creating some sort of art masterpiece, or discovering the cure for cancer. No one wins a Nobel Prize for making a FM tactic. So get a life, it's just a computer game, meant to be fun. I've shared a few tweaked tactics in the past, because I was having fun and succeeding with it, and wanted to share my fun with the community. So if someone makes a small tweak that performs better, brilliant! More fun and wins for everyone. That should be the purpose.
Bini said: Man, this tactic is simply outstanding! The attacking football is beautiful, the build up is amazing and it’s really really strong defensively!! I’m using it now, I made two small adjustments. One made the tactic less powerful and the other I think made it a small bit better… 1) I changed a little bit the corner routines so it doesn’t become a tactic which has a CD with 40 goals a season. And because the tactic is so good, I’m still been winning the games by far. 2) just for the Right and Left defenders (wingers) I removed the instruction to tackle harder, and I’ve been checking that they perform relatively better. I thought that, in the middle of the field, you need aggression and bravery fighting for the ball. But because the winger are playing “alone” on the sides, if they go “with it all” to win the ball, sometimes they will get overrun by the opponent, and by removing the tackle harder from them, I noticed they became more conservative and more ‘intelligent’ on when to fight for the ball.
Still, this tactic is completely the best and most realistic tactic I’ve tried so far (after almost 2000 hours of FM23). It’s great to see a different shape than the 424. Great job and great eye on the game and on tactics you have ! Congratulations 💪🏻 Expand
Champion in Sweden with a lesser team, then hired by Boavista in December (16th in the league), to finish 3rd and win the portuguese cup! And now dominating the league. I just love the fact that we conceded ZERO in the last 13 league matches.
I was kind of divided between this and Alhamdullilah II, but must say this is for me the best tactic I've tried this year. Lots of clean sheets, great attack, the football played is beautiful. Will share some pics later.
x360wizard said: Won the CL first season with RB Leipzig using this, doesn't concede a lot and scores enough, However the CWB's do not perform well at all Angelinho is my worst performer regularly putting in anywhere from 6.1 to 6.4 with a yellow card. Expand
I think the CWB ratings are very influenced by goals and assists. All you need is a cross to a goal, sometimes from a corner, and you have a nice solid rating!
Being a fan of wingerless tactics, I've always tried to make wingerless tweaked versions of my favourite tactics in the last versions of FM. And must say this year's version based in chicken wing 4123 has been huge for me, in several saves, in different scenarios and countries. I'm now sharing because I really feel this is the one for this year, and I'm sharing the first two seasons of the last save I'll play this year, and that I'll try to go as far in time as possible!
Started in Sweden with a team predicted last, with a transfer embargo, had to play (and retrain) wingers as CM, to play a few 16/17 year kids with a CA of 80, so a big challenge! Ended as champion!!!
Then took the Hammarby job, big club in Sweden, that rarely wins the title and the performance has been amazing so far, as you can see.
The problem I'm having now is that my players are performing so well, the clubs in the top leagues are literally bullying my club and totally disrupting my players, that are forcing they way out!!!
Two things are sure with this tactic: Your defense is going to be SOLID, really SOLID (lots of clean sheets) Your two strikers will score loads (probably the two top scorers in the league)
A couple of tips: The central mid must be an offensive player, we will score a few also. The two CWB must have strong physical attributes and be fast, as they will run a lot, make sure to always have two CWB subs ready to enter.
If against lesser opponents you feel that are having trouble scoring is because your strikers are performing poorly, just sub them, no matter the quality they have, It's not their day.
Here's a quick update. With my hometown very small club Cova da Piedade, and after winning the second division tittle in the first season, finished 2nd in the league in the second season, so direct to Champions League group stage. That's really tough in Portugal, due to the huge quality difference between the big three + Braga and the rest of the clubs. For my third season got Besiktas, Man Utd and PSG in the CL group, so maybe I can get that 3rd place for Europa League! Just beated Besiktas 2-0 at home, so it started well! It's funny I don't even have a proper stadium for the league, so I play on another stadium, but that stadium is not enough for CL, so i CL I play in yet another stadium!!! They plan to build a new one, but it will take alot of time... And the team, a simple and normal bunch of very average players, no super regens or stars. Actually for the first time in alot of years I'm not using genie scout, and just using the ingame scouts recomendations, and they work just fine.
Just get the best players you can and plug and play. Once the the team gets used to it, its very very strong. Not much else to say, don't overcomplicate things, keep it simple as it is.
DoubleR said: It’s one of the most consistent tactics I have ever played, you are totally right. But it’s a dimartino tweak who might be one of the best tacticians around, so that alone interests me Expand
That's clearly an overstatement, as I just tweak tacticas from the top tacticians. Obviously I understand that Phoenix is one of the best tactics around, but I don't know why, I was not getting consistent results. Dominating almost every match with high xG, failing tons of easy chances, but a lot of unfair of 1-0, 2-1 losses. With this one I'm scoring more, with consistent good results, and it seems like the opposition has a hard time playing against me. I don't like to waste my or your time with nonsence. When I share something, it's because I really think it's worthy. A bit surprised with the test result, but It's not the first time something that really works for me, to have a bad test result.
Tweaked from this https://fm-arena.com/thread/9824-4213-striker-madness-v5/
Well said. It would be nice some people stopped behaving like they are creating some sort of art masterpiece, or discovering the cure for cancer. No one wins a Nobel Prize for making a FM tactic. So get a life, it's just a computer game, meant to be fun. I've shared a few tweaked tactics in the past, because I was having fun and succeeding with it, and wanted to share my fun with the community. So if someone makes a small tweak that performs better, brilliant! More fun and wins for everyone. That should be the purpose.
I’m using it now, I made two small adjustments. One made the tactic less powerful and the other I think made it a small bit better…
1) I changed a little bit the corner routines so it doesn’t become a tactic which has a CD with 40 goals a season. And because the tactic is so good, I’m still been winning the games by far.
2) just for the Right and Left defenders (wingers) I removed the instruction to tackle harder, and I’ve been checking that they perform relatively better. I thought that, in the middle of the field, you need aggression and bravery fighting for the ball. But because the winger are playing “alone” on the sides, if they go “with it all” to win the ball, sometimes they will get overrun by the opponent, and by removing the tackle harder from them, I noticed they became more conservative and more ‘intelligent’ on when to fight for the ball.
Still, this tactic is completely the best and most realistic tactic I’ve tried so far (after almost 2000 hours of FM23). It’s great to see a different shape than the 424.
Great job and great eye on the game and on tactics you have ! Congratulations 💪🏻
HEAR! HEAR!
I think the CWB ratings are very influenced by goals and assists. All you need is a cross to a goal, sometimes from a corner, and you have a nice solid rating!
Being a fan of wingerless tactics, I've always tried to make wingerless tweaked versions of my favourite tactics in the last versions of FM.
And must say this year's version based in chicken wing 4123 has been huge for me, in several saves, in different scenarios and countries. I'm now sharing because I really feel this is the one for this year, and I'm sharing the first two seasons of the last save I'll play this year, and that I'll try to go as far in time as possible!
Started in Sweden with a team predicted last, with a transfer embargo, had to play (and retrain) wingers as CM, to play a few 16/17 year kids with a CA of 80, so a big challenge! Ended as champion!!!
Then took the Hammarby job, big club in Sweden, that rarely wins the title and the performance has been amazing so far, as you can see.
The problem I'm having now is that my players are performing so well, the clubs in the top leagues are literally bullying my club and totally disrupting my players, that are forcing they way out!!!
Two things are sure with this tactic:
Your defense is going to be SOLID, really SOLID (lots of clean sheets)
Your two strikers will score loads (probably the two top scorers in the league)
A couple of tips:
The central mid must be an offensive player, we will score a few also.
The two CWB must have strong physical attributes and be fast, as they will run a lot, make sure to always have two CWB subs ready to enter.
If against lesser opponents you feel that are having trouble scoring is because your strikers are performing poorly, just sub them, no matter the quality they have, It's not their day.
HAVE FUN
And the team, a simple and normal bunch of very average players, no super regens or stars. Actually for the first time in alot of years I'm not using genie scout, and just using the ingame scouts recomendations, and they work just fine.
Can you guys test it?
Can you guys test it?
That's clearly an overstatement, as I just tweak tacticas from the top tacticians. Obviously I understand that Phoenix is one of the best tactics around, but I don't know why, I was not getting consistent results. Dominating almost every match with high xG, failing tons of easy chances, but a lot of unfair of 1-0, 2-1 losses. With this one I'm scoring more, with consistent good results, and it seems like the opposition has a hard time playing against me. I don't like to waste my or your time with nonsence. When I share something, it's because I really think it's worthy. A bit surprised with the test result, but It's not the first time something that really works for me, to have a bad test result.