Mark said: It sounds to me like your ratings file has been altered some how.
I have manually calculated the ratings using both MDW22 and MDW24 ratings values. The calculation is, each attribute score multiplied by the ratings file weighting for the attribute for the position you are calculating. Then divided by the total attribute weighting for the position. And then divided by 20. You then also need to apply the Weight for that position in the rating file, which is where the balancing across positions occurs.
I have assumed they are both strikers.
For MDW24 I make it Ergin 52.38% to Samed 59.15%.
For MDW22 I make it Ergin 51.48% to Samed 58.09%
The difference between the two sets of ratings is in the balancing, the Weight for the position in the rating file. This is how the FS position relates to other positions which I fixed with the rebalancing. Proportionally within the positions MDW22 and MDW24 are the same but there have been some slight changes across positions. For instance in FM24 Haaland wasn't the top player using MDW22 but now is with MDW24. The changes came by comparing across positions based on a standard player as opposed to the best of each position when I did MDW22.
If you load the ratings file you are interested in and then go into Rating/Edit Player Rating you can see the Weight used for each position.
I hope this helps. Expand
I think, something in background of Genie affect ratings very much. Cause i delete all ratings in genie then make corners weight 100 for only rating for FS. Then FS Position 20 all players with 10 corners attributes are rating for FS between %45-%56 but i expect that all FS rating should be %50. Also i cant find reasonable cause for this different ratings.
kvasir said: Which one do you prefer? I haven’t tried MDW22. Expand
MDW22 is great for me in FM22. But for honest Zaz Blue tactic is amazing in FM22 so maybe player decision do not affect that much but in FM23 it is important.
Mark said: Both are good. I have been using my MDW22 and still am Expand
For lower leagues MDW22 and ykykyk is difference a lot. When I change calculations they recommend different players for positons in FM23. It is confusing.
Mark said: Role rating doesnt really matter. Positional rating is important but it also matters if the are Natural for the position or 20/20 for the position in Genie Scout rating.
ykykyky was the one developed using machine learning for ZaZ Blue tactic. I still used MDW22 and still do. Expand
thanks for answering. you mean if Raphinha is 18/20 for AMR positon and Damsgaard is 20/20 for AMR positon, I should choose Damsgaard?
Has anyone seen something like that? Rival team have substitutions to do but some players comes off but no one comes on to the game? in first image Sadiku comes off in 10. minutes. second one donk comes off in 1. minutes.
Hello people, is this tactics causes more red card because of the updates. I was not playing fm21 for 3 months and i opened my old save. 3 matches 3 red cards. have a great Sunday.
@Magician If I draw or lose with Phoenix v5.0 tactic after the 1st half then should change the mentality to "Very Attacking" at the beginning of the 2nd half or should i use very attacking tactic that you made?
I have manually calculated the ratings using both MDW22 and MDW24 ratings values. The calculation is, each attribute score multiplied by the ratings file weighting for the attribute for the position you are calculating. Then divided by the total attribute weighting for the position. And then divided by 20. You then also need to apply the Weight for that position in the rating file, which is where the balancing across positions occurs.
I have assumed they are both strikers.
For MDW24 I make it Ergin 52.38% to Samed 59.15%.
For MDW22 I make it Ergin 51.48% to Samed 58.09%
The difference between the two sets of ratings is in the balancing, the Weight for the position in the rating file. This is how the FS position relates to other positions which I fixed with the rebalancing. Proportionally within the positions MDW22 and MDW24 are the same but there have been some slight changes across positions. For instance in FM24 Haaland wasn't the top player using MDW22 but now is with MDW24. The changes came by comparing across positions based on a standard player as opposed to the best of each position when I did MDW22.
If you load the ratings file you are interested in and then go into Rating/Edit Player Rating you can see the Weight used for each position.
I hope this helps.
I think, something in background of Genie affect ratings very much. Cause i delete all ratings in genie then make corners weight 100 for only rating for FS. Then FS Position 20 all players with 10 corners attributes are rating for FS between %45-%56 but i expect that all FS rating should be %50. Also i cant find reasonable cause for this different ratings.
Mark said: If you link to the game file I will have a look. I have done the manual calcs and Samad comes out a long way in front.
MDW24 rating says Ergin is better. Anyone know why?
MDW22 is great for me in FM22. But for honest Zaz Blue tactic is amazing in FM22 so maybe player decision do not affect that much but in FM23 it is important.
For lower leagues MDW22 and ykykyk is difference a lot. When I change calculations they recommend different players for positons in FM23. It is confusing.
do you use MDW22 or ykykyk files in genie scout 23? or are there any rating file fit better for 23?
ykykyky was the one developed using machine learning for ZaZ Blue tactic. I still used MDW22 and still do.
thanks for answering. you mean if Raphinha is 18/20 for AMR positon and Damsgaard is 20/20 for AMR positon, I should choose Damsgaard?
YKYKYKY
MDW22
Zaz
Which one is better for Zaz Blue?
Im using ZaZ - Blue 4.0. For AMR positon I have Damsgaard and Raphinha.
Positional Rating
Raphinha 84
Damsgaard 83,5
Role Rating For Winger Support Role
Raphinha 88
Damsgaard 91
Which player do you choose?
Rival team have substitutions to do but some players comes off but no one comes on to the game?
in first image Sadiku comes off in 10. minutes.
second one donk comes off in 1. minutes.
it seems like you add more direct passing to very attacking tactic. Thats why i wanted to ask. i will only change the mentality.