Dezhy said: @Bafici I appreciate the good work you have done here but what about the position values a player has? I mean there was a test two years ago for player positions, which basically says even 1 point in player position has an impact on the tactic. Expand
I can't change positional values but the program takes them into account already. You can search by position to be sure.
When i go two away games in a week it becomes like this
I think the game has a bug. Sometimes on sunday, it removes one of the recovery sessions and changes it to rest even though it doesn't clash with anything. You can manually add.
Orion said: Just to keep you guys up to date I've decided to make a small adjustment for the features that use two attributes - so the last one for MLR and the last one for Striker. I've decided to take square of a product from multiplication those features (SQR(Attribute1 * Attribute2) * Coefficient). This way you can keep it proportional to the coefficient. I don't know how it works with your files. I assume that for spreadsheet it's not an issue. What about GenieScout? Does it support other mathematical operations? If not I'd suggest just to get rid of those 2 features (since they are last important for given positions) and adjust others to sum up to 100% just like you did for the other positions. Expand
Genie doesn't allow such mathematical operations unfortunately. Spreadsheet would be 1:1 replica of the coefficients. If you have time and patience i would suggest using the spreadsheet. You can still use the Genie ratings they are very close to spreadsheet.
johnconnerson said: Are there any meta GS ratings files that integrate hidden attributes like Important Matches or Consistency? I feel like those could definitely sway my opinion on who to bring into my club. Expand
You can't intergrate them into ratings unfortunately. You can put a filter when you are searching
CBP87 said: @Bafici can you share how you got those GS ratings please? It might just be me but I can't make sense of the Coefficient scoring on the opening thread Expand
I match the highest number to 100 and scale the rest according to that. Like this for example.
GK Agi (0,014640/0,014640)*100 = 100 Ref (0,012837/0,014640)*100 = 88 Aer (0,011812/0,014640)*100 = 81 Thr (0,007465/0,014640)*100 = 51 Com (0,007436/0,014640)*100 = 51 Han (0,006255/0,014640)*100 = 43 Dec (0,005089/0,014640)*100 = 35
Middleweight165 said: Thanks! On 1st glance they seem a bit unbalanced. Best GK is 78% whereas best ST is 88%. I suppose it doesnt really matter if we are just picking the best player from the list though. Also seems to be an error on the ST. Don't know if it's with me or the ratings but when looking at my own team all ST ratings are 0.00% Expand
I didn't touch the weightings because i need to make calculations to make the best players rating %100. Like @kvasir said Haaland becomes 99% but if a player has 20 in all the important attributes his rating can past %100. After all its just a cosmetic thing.
Y15ARG said: I get an error whenever I try to use your ratings.glf Layout file: 'List index out of bounds (8193) Expand
Can you try to change the layout after you load the players. I think there is a bug, if it doesn'T work you can use the normal layout or create one yourself.
flob said: I don't know if it's just me overthinking it, but I still find it a bit rough regarding positions, because both striker positions in your view say that my strikers are not the best for it's potition. I use advanced forward attack, but unsure how to look at it as your view has FS/TS. Expand
Roles doesn't matter in terms of attribute requirements. FS is the exact ratings with the tests. I would use this one for Advanced Forward.
In TS i made jumping reach a bit more important, nothing else is different. This can score more if you aim corners to this player.
Ivanacco1 said: I cannot seem to get fmgenie to get working, im on gamepass and it doesnt detect my game. Expand
Update the program maybe. I'm on gamepass too. It works.
flob said: Thanks for sharing, I have some follow up questions if you don't mind:
- When opening FM Genie Scout and putting on your layout and ratings. When I close the app and open it again, let's say tomorrow, will the ratings still be loaded or do I have to do that part every time? I noticed the layout stays, just wondering if that's the same for ratings.
- When looking for a player, do you have an .. amount of % you aim for as a bare minimum? Let's say I look for a new AMR, do I only look at 70%+ best position rating? Reason for asking, most players seem to be extremily expensive so I was wondering how people deal with this. Expand
Everything will be still loaded.
I don't have a minimum rating in my mind because i don't know the maximum rating in that position. I just sort best to worst. You can check your squads rating and then apply that rating as minimum.
There is a lot of questions regarding how to do certain things in Genie Scout(GS) so i hope this helps.
First we need to setup the program to suit our needs.
1-You need to download This ratings file (OR This from @Pip and put it in C:\FM Genie Scout 24\Ratings.
You need to download This layout file and put it in C:\FM Genie Scout 24\Layouts.
2-Open GS and from top left select the files we just put in.
3-Open FM and load your save. Go back to GS and Select Load Game or click on the little icon next to GS icon. You will see a loading bar down below. This process can take a minute depending on how many players in your save.
4-After everything is loaded click on Red Filter button.I don't want players who have lower than 120 PA. You can search for everything you want.
5-These are all the players in the game who has 120PA at least. Down below you can see there is 27.304 players. You can sort the players according to positions.
6-I can hear you say "i don't want to see every player, i only want to see the players who are interested in joining me.". Don't worry, i got you covered.
After you filter the players you want, Press CTRL+A > Right Click > Add players. This will add all the players into "my shortlist" tab.
Go to that tab and save shortlist. Go into game > load this shortlist and put a tick "interested in" box. You assistant will filter the players who wants to join the club.
7-While you're in shortlist screen in the game click this button in GS and voila! Now you only see the players who are interested in your club.
Feel free to ask further questions. There might be parts hard to understand. I can edit in my free time.
** You can view your own squad if you click this button and type your club name.
It always shows error messages, so you can delete it.
Nothing special. Apply the same routines
[Defending from the Front]+[Double Intensity]+[Addtional Focus Quickness]
Is this the best one for the just meta attributes, not all rounded development.
I mean there was a test two years ago for player positions, which basically says even 1 point in player position has an impact on the tactic.
I can't change positional values but the program takes them into account already. You can search by position to be sure.
When i go two away games in a week it becomes like this
I think the game has a bug. Sometimes on sunday, it removes one of the recovery sessions and changes it to rest even though it doesn't clash with anything. You can manually add.
I don't know how it works with your files. I assume that for spreadsheet it's not an issue.
What about GenieScout? Does it support other mathematical operations? If not I'd suggest just to get rid of those 2 features (since they are last important for given positions) and adjust others to sum up to 100% just like you did for the other positions.
Genie doesn't allow such mathematical operations unfortunately.
Spreadsheet would be 1:1 replica of the coefficients. If you have time and patience i would suggest using the spreadsheet. You can still use the Genie ratings they are very close to spreadsheet.
Just use this one.
[Quickness]+[Match Practice]+[Attacking]+[Recovery]x7+[Double Intensity]+[Addtional Focus Quickness]
You can't intergrate them into ratings unfortunately. You can put a filter when you are searching
I match the highest number to 100 and scale the rest according to that.
Like this for example.
GK
Agi (0,014640/0,014640)*100 = 100
Ref (0,012837/0,014640)*100 = 88
Aer (0,011812/0,014640)*100 = 81
Thr (0,007465/0,014640)*100 = 51
Com (0,007436/0,014640)*100 = 51
Han (0,006255/0,014640)*100 = 43
Dec (0,005089/0,014640)*100 = 35
Numbers are rounded.
I didn't touch the weightings because i need to make calculations to make the best players rating %100. Like @kvasir said Haaland becomes 99% but if a player has 20 in all the important attributes his rating can past %100. After all its just a cosmetic thing.
Ratings
Can you try to change the layout after you load the players. I think there is a bug, if it doesn'T work you can use the normal layout or create one yourself.
Depends on my team. I try to buy the highest rating i can. I can't sign 80 rating player when playing in English league 2 for example.
I also mainly look at sale value besides rating. I'm chasing bargains. Can't spend 100 mil on a player
Roles doesn't matter in terms of attribute requirements. FS is the exact ratings with the tests. I would use this one for Advanced Forward.
In TS i made jumping reach a bit more important, nothing else is different. This can score more if you aim corners to this player.
Update the program maybe. I'm on gamepass too. It works.
flob said: Thanks for sharing, I have some follow up questions if you don't mind:
- When opening FM Genie Scout and putting on your layout and ratings. When I close the app and open it again, let's say tomorrow, will the ratings still be loaded or do I have to do that part every time? I noticed the layout stays, just wondering if that's the same for ratings.
- When looking for a player, do you have an .. amount of % you aim for as a bare minimum? Let's say I look for a new AMR, do I only look at 70%+ best position rating? Reason for asking, most players seem to be extremily expensive so I was wondering how people deal with this.
Everything will be still loaded.
I don't have a minimum rating in my mind because i don't know the maximum rating in that position. I just sort best to worst. You can check your squads rating and then apply that rating as minimum.
Ahh sorry there is a mistake. I edited it but didn't save so when you upload you see a different layout.
**Fixed Layout(Same With the opening post)
https://drive.google.com/file/d/12XgWvSLHiAPJRrDrq3xJiRyLYcquE_u-/view?usp=sharing
There is a lot of questions regarding how to do certain things in Genie Scout(GS) so i hope this helps.
First we need to setup the program to suit our needs.
1-You need to download This ratings file (OR This from @Pip and put it in C:\FM Genie Scout 24\Ratings.
You need to download This layout file and put it in C:\FM Genie Scout 24\Layouts.
2-Open GS and from top left select the files we just put in.
3-Open FM and load your save. Go back to GS and Select Load Game or click on the little icon next to GS icon. You will see a loading bar down below. This process can take a minute depending on how many players in your save.
4-After everything is loaded click on Red Filter button.I don't want players who have lower than 120 PA. You can search for everything you want.
5-These are all the players in the game who has 120PA at least. Down below you can see there is 27.304 players. You can sort the players according to positions.
6-I can hear you say "i don't want to see every player, i only want to see the players who are interested in joining me.". Don't worry, i got you covered.
After you filter the players you want, Press CTRL+A > Right Click > Add players. This will add all the players into "my shortlist" tab.
Go to that tab and save shortlist. Go into game > load this shortlist and put a tick "interested in" box. You assistant will filter the players who wants to join the club.
7-While you're in shortlist screen in the game click this button in GS and voila! Now you only see the players who are interested in your club.
Feel free to ask further questions. There might be parts hard to understand. I can edit in my free time.
** You can view your own squad if you click this button and type your club name.