Summary of recent findings for optimal play in FM24

Step 2: Each template has a "style"

The game gives every template a style by adding up three of its multipliers in each group below. The highest total wins.

StyleThe three attributes added
AttackingFinishing + Off the Ball + Vision
DefendingMarking + Tackling + Positioning
FitnessStrength + Stamina + Pace
TacticalOff the Ball + Decisions + Vision
TechnicalTechnique + First Touch + Dribbling
MentalBravery + Concentration + Work Rate
Set piecesCorners + Free Kicks + Long Throws

A tie goes to whichever style is higher in the table. But if the average of the Attacking, Defending and Fitness totals is more than 80% of the winning total, the template is "all-rounder" instead.

Example. A template with Technical total 4.2, Attacking 3.0, Defending 2.4 and Fitness 3.3. Technical wins with 4.2. The average of Attacking, Defending and Fitness is (3.0 + 2.4 + 3.3) ÷ 3 = 2.9. 80% of 4.2 is 3.36. 2.9 is not above 3.36, so it's a Technical template.

Step 3: Your HoYD's coaching style

Your HoYD gets a style the same way, from his coaching attributes. His highest attribute out of Attacking, Defending, Tactical, Technical, Mental, Fitness and one more hidden value wins. Ties go to the first one in that list. The hidden value counts as "Set pieces". I couldn't match it to anything you can see in-game.

He's an all-rounder instead if the average of all of those except Mental, rounded down, is more than 80% of his highest.

Examples.
  • Attacking 16, Defending 12, Fitness 10, Mental 14, Technical 15, Tactical 13, hidden value 8. The average without Mental is (16 + 12 + 10 + 15 + 13 + 8) ÷ 6 = 12.3, rounded down to 12. 80% of 16 is 12.8. 12 is not above 12.8, so he's an Attacking HoYD.
  • Attacking 14, Defending 14, Fitness 13, Mental 12, Technical 15, Tactical 14, hidden value 12. The average is 82 ÷ 6 = 13.7, rounded down to 13. 80% of 15 is 12. 13 is above 12, so he's an all-rounder.

With no HoYD, there's no style and no bias.

Step 4: Picking the template — region, and the HoYD's nudge

Which region.


  • If the new player's nation has a playable league, he uses his nation's templates.
  • If not, the game uses his continent's templates to set the size of the roll (below). Then it uses the roll itself as a coin flip: if the roll is an even number it walks only his continent's templates, and if it's odd it walks the whole list* (every nation and continent).
That odd-roll half looks like a bug. The roll is sized for his continent's templates alone, but the walk starts at the front of the whole list, and the list starts with the continent sets in this order: South America, Oceania, North America, Europe, Asia, Africa. So on an odd roll, he nearly always gets a template from the first continent sets in that order that have templates for his position, whatever his own continent. I confirmed this live (see "What the templates look like in a real save" below): most odd-roll Europeans got South or North American templates.

Example. A Scottish youngster, with Scotland not playable. Say his continent's templates for his position and height have a total weight of 300, so the roll is 0–299. On an even roll he gets a European template as you'd expect. On an odd roll, the walk starts with South America's templates for his position. It only reaches Europe's if the roll is larger than the weight of every template ahead of them.

If nothing gets picked (for example, his nation has no templates for his position and height), the game tries again over the whole list and sizes the roll for the whole list.

The roll. The game lines up the matching templates and rolls a number from 0 up to (total weight − 1). The total only counts templates in his region, for his positions and his height band. It then walks down the list, counting off each template's weight, and stops at the first template in his height band where the count reaches the roll.

Two things take a share from templates further down the list:
  • Templates of the other height bands use up the count as the game walks past them, even though they can't be picked and weren't in the total.
  • A template with the same style as your HoYD counts double, but the total the roll came from does not include the doubling.
Example. Three templates in this order, each with weight 10 and in his height band: A (Technical), B (Attacking), C (Defending). The total is 30, so the roll is 0–29.
  • No HoYD: A takes rolls 0–10 (11 in 30, 37%). B takes 11–20 (33%) and C takes 21–29 (30%).
  • Technical HoYD: A counts 20, so it takes rolls 0–20 (70%). B takes 21–29 (30%). C can never be picked.
  • Defending HoYD: C is last, so doubling it changes nothing: 37% / 33% / 30%.
  • No HoYD, but a 10-weight template for a different height sits between A and B: the total is still 30. A takes 0–10. The other-height template uses up 11–20 but can't be picked, so those rolls fall through to B, which takes 11–29 (63%). C can never be picked.

So a matching style gets up to double the chance, depending on where its templates sit in the list. Because the most common template for each role comes first (Step 1b, point 6), the HoYD's nudge does the most for the most common templates for each role.

When the template matches his style, the HoYD is also added to the player's list of important people. My guess is that's how he shows up as one of the youngster's favoured personnel, but I haven't confirmed it.

Step 5: Turning the template into attributes

For each attribute:
  1. Base value. The game works out a level for the player's CA: CA ÷ 20 + 6.5, rounded down. It works out a second level the same way from either his PA (1 time in 3) or a random number between his CA and PA. The base is somewhere between the two levels.
  2. Position importance. Attributes that matter for his position get a random bonus, and ones that don't can lose a little. The result is kept within 1–20.
  3. Template value = base × the template's multiplier for that attribute, rounded down and kept within 1–20.
  4. The template value usually wins. About 23 times in 24, the attribute is replaced:
    • If the template value is at least the base, the new value is the template value −2 to +2.
    • Otherwise it's the template value +0 to +2.
    • Then, 1 time in 4, it's averaged with the CA level from point 1, rounded down.

      If the attribute would naturally have come out higher than the template value, there's an extra 1-in-20 chance the higher value is kept. A few attributes have extra checks of their own.
Example. CA 80 and PA 160. The CA level is 80 ÷ 20 + 6.5 = 10.5, rounded down to 10. Say the PA was used for Pace: 160 ÷ 20 + 6.5 = 14.5, so 14. The base is 10 plus a random 0–3, so 10–13. Say it's 12, and position importance leaves it at 12.
  • The winger template has ×1.3 Pace: 12 × 1.3 = 15.6, rounded down to 15. 15 is at least 12, so Pace becomes 13–17. 1 time in 4, say he rolled 16, it's averaged with the CA level instead: (10 + 16) ÷ 2 = 13.
  • The same template has ×0.6 Heading. With a base of 12: 12 × 0.6 = 7.2, so 7. 7 is below 12, so Heading becomes 7–9.

After this the game does one more pass over all the attributes. I haven't traced it fully, but it looks like it tidies them to fit his CA.

Bottom line: the attribute spread comes from the template, picked by position, height and region, and scaled by CA and PA. Your HoYD's strongest coaching attribute makes templates of that style up to twice as likely. His formation and tactics play no part.
 
What the templates look like in a real save

I read the whole template list out of a running save. I also logged every template pick on a March intake day: 62 youngsters across all the clubs with an intake that day. The rules in Steps 1–5 reproduced every single pick exactly. England is the only playable nation in this save, so the numbers below are for this save. Yours will differ, but the patterns should be similar.

The list. There are 335 templates, built from 10,091 real senior players.

RegionTemplates
England (its own set, because it's playable)75
Europe76
South America60
Africa51
North America45
Asia28
Oceania0 (every one was too rare and got deleted, Step 1b point 5)

The styles. "Share" is the style's share of the total weight, which is roughly how often it's in play.

StyleTemplatesShare
All-rounder22062%
Technical8130%
Mental176% (all 16 goalkeepers, plus one European pressing forward)
Fitness91.2%
Attacking40.6%
Tactical30.4%
Defending10.1%
Set pieces00%

So an all-rounder HoYD has something to boost in most positions, a Technical HoYD in many attacking ones, and a Mental HoYD for keepers only. An Attacking, Defending, Tactical, Fitness or Set-piece HoYD has almost nothing to boost.

The odd-roll quirk is strong. 36 youngsters in my intake were from European nations without a playable league. 18 rolled even and got European templates. Of the 18 who rolled odd, only 4 got a European template. 9 got a South American one and 5 a North American one. Two European keepers (177–185 cm) both got the same North American sweeper-keeper template.

Many shapes can never appear. Templates of other heights eat into the roll as the game walks past them (Step 4). In some positions that means the first template of the youngster's height always wins, and the rest are never reached.

Example: a tall English striker (186 cm or more, natural only up front). The striker templates for his height are Advanced Forward 27, Target Man 56, Poacher 11 and Pressing Forward 13. The total is 107, so the roll is 0–106. But the list is in role order, and other heights come first:
  • Deep-Lying Forward (177–185 cm), weight 17;
  • Advanced Forward (177–185 cm), weight 63;
  • Advanced Forward (under 177 cm), weight 33;
  • Advanced Forward (186 cm+), weight 27: the first one of his height.
By the time the walk reaches it, the count is 17 + 63 + 33 = 113, already more than any roll. So he always gets the Advanced Forward template. Target Man is the most common shape among real tall English strikers, and it never appears.

What English youngsters actually get. This is for a youngster natural in one position, with no HoYD:


PositionUnder 177 cm177–185 cm186 cm+
Goalkeeperno template (below)Goalkeeper 100%Goalkeeper 66%, Sweeper Keeper 34%
Full-backWing-Back 100%Full-Back 11%, Wing-Back 43%, Complete Wing-Back 46%Wing-Back 100%
Centre-backno template (below)Central Defender 100%Central Defender 67%, Ball-Playing Defender 33%
Wing-backWing-Back 100%Wing-Back 56%, Complete Wing-Back 44%Wing-Back 100%
Defensive midfielderDeep-Lying Playmaker 100%Deep-Lying Playmaker 36%, Ball-Winning Midfielder 64%Defensive Midfielder 18%, Deep-Lying Playmaker 82%
Central midfielderDeep-Lying Playmaker 48%, Box-to-Box 52%Deep-Lying Playmaker 17%, Box-to-Box 27%, Advanced Playmaker 45%, Ball-Winning Midfielder 11%Box-to-Box 100%
Wide midfielderWinger 100%Winger 83%, Defensive Winger 17%Winger 100%
Attacking midfielderAttacking Midfielder 32%, Advanced Playmaker 68%Attacking Midfielder 49%, Advanced Playmaker 51%Advanced Playmaker 100%
WingerWinger 100%Winger 69%, Advanced Playmaker 31%Winger 100%
StrikerAdvanced Forward 100%Deep-Lying Forward 12%, Advanced Forward 42%, Target Man 46%Advanced Forward 100%

These shapes never appear for these youngsters in this save, even though the templates exist: Inverted Full-Back, Libero, Wide Centre-Back, Mezzala, Wide Playmaker, Shadow Striker, Inside Forward, Wide Target Man, False Nine, Poacher and Pressing Forward. Sweeper Keeper only appears at 186 cm+, Ball-Playing Defender only at 186 cm+, Target Man only at 177–185 cm, and Complete Wing-Back and Ball-Winning Midfielder only at 177–185 cm.

Two things change the table:
  • Youngsters natural in more than one position. 35 of the 63 youngsters in my intake were, e.g. left-back and left wing-back. The templates for all their positions go into one pool, so their odds differ from the table.
  • Short keepers and centre-backs. There are no goalkeeper or centre-back templates for under 177 cm anywhere in the list: too few real players that short, so they were deleted. A keeper or centre-back under 177 cm, natural only in that position, gets no template at all**. Point 4 of Step 5 is skipped, and his attributes come from the base value and position importance alone. One keeper in my intake was like this.
What each HoYD style actually does here (English youngsters, one natural position):

HoYD stylePosition and heightNo HoYDWith this HoYD
All-rounderFull-back, 177–185 cmFull-Back 11%, Wing-Back 43%, Complete Wing-Back 46%Full-Back 22%, Wing-Back 78%, Complete Wing-Back 0%
Al-rounderCentre-back, 186 cm+Central Defender 67%, Ball-Playing Defender 33%Central Defender 100%
Al-rounderCentral midfielder, 177–185 cmDeep-Lying Playmaker 17%, Box-to-Box 27%, Advanced Playmaker 45%, Ball-Winning Midfielder 11%Deep-Lying Playmaker 34%, Box-to-Box 54%, Advanced Playmaker 12%, Ball-Winning Midfielder 0%
Al-rounderCentral midfielder, under 177 cmDeep-Lying Playmaker 48%, Box-to-Box 52%Deep-Lying Playmaker 9 %, Box-to-Box 6%
Al-rounderStriker, 177–185 cmDeep-Lying Forward 12%, Advanced Forward 42%, Target Man 46%Deep-Lying Forward 23%, Advanced Forward 77%, Target Man 0%
TechnicalAttacking midfielder (centre), 177–185 cm Attacking Midfielder 49%, Advanced Playmaker 51%Attacking Midfielder 97%, Advanced Playmaker 3%
TechnicalWinger, 177–185 cm | Winger 69%, Advanced Playmaker 31%Winger 100%
MentalGoalkeeper, 186 cm+Goalkeeper 66%, Sweeper Keeper 34%Goalkeeper 100 %
 
Two lessons:
  • It's a reshuffle, not "more of that style". In the under-177 cm central midfielder row, both templates are all-rounders. The all-rounder HoYD still pushes Box-to-Box down from 52% to 6%. The doubling helps whichever matching template comes first in the list, and takes the share from everything after it, whatever its style.
  • Shapes, not quality. CA and PA are already set before this (Parts 4–6). The template only decides which attributes are high and which are low.
Bottom line: the attribute spread comes from the template, picked by position, height and region, and scaled by CA and PA. The templates are averages of real players in your save: a youngster from a playable nation is shaped like that nation's senior players in his position. Your HoYD's strongest coaching attribute makes templates of that style up to twice as likely. In practice only an all-rounder, Technical or Mental (keepers only) HoYD has much to work with. Even then, he reshuffles which shapes arrive rather than making them better. Because of how the pick works, many shapes can never appear at all. His formation and tactics play no part.

---

God I'm glad that's over with. That was not enjoyable. This really isn't the place for almost 1,000 lines of information. I'd kill to be able to see my character count as I'm typing, too.
 
Back
Top