White Europe said: Any of you tried xbox version on PC? I had 2022 version but is not the same when you have to copy all tactics yourself manualy, i wonder if anyone have any experience with xbox version 2023 on pc? Expand
I haven't tried an Xbox version PC but I think the experience it'll be more or less like in the past FM Touch version on PC.
I think you have to copy all tactics manually only if you play in a console or a mobile but if you play on a PC then it should be Ok.
Yarema said: "There's a lot of factors that come in to play e.g. movement speed of players, bravery, strength, body position. It's rare that two players with the same jumping reach will be differentiated by their height since its extremely unlikely that these other factors are also going to all be the same. Personally I just look at jumping reach when judging players, never really check the height since it's factored in."
That's the only post I've found from an actual SI guy Expand
If I had fee time then I'll look for the post I mentioned. Btw, there's also a hint in the game, it appears on the processing screen and it also says that Height also matters. Of course, as I said it might make a very small difference like 1-2% but still.
Yarema said: Height doesn't matter in terms of aerial ability. 170 cm with 15 jumping reach is just as good as 190 cm with 15. However obviously taller players will tend to have those attributes higher. Expand
That's not true.
I remember someone asked that on the official SI forum and one of the dev team answered that a 190cm player with 15 Jumping Reach should out jump a 170 cm player with 15 Jumping Reach.
So "Height" matters after all but the tests show its impact is very small, it's really not worth bothering, there're many other attributes that have much bigger impact on the game.
kjordafen said: Can you share or link to the very low intensity tactic you used? Expand
It's just a few tweaks
Mentality to "Cautious" Time Wasting to "Maximum" Removing "Counter" Removing "Counter-Press" Tempo to "Minimum" Trigger Press to "Standard" Line Of Engagement to "Mid Block"
Also, I moved the left Striker to the left AM position.
I usually used it when I was up 2-3 goals in matches or for friendly matches.
GROM said: you play in balanced mentality every match? Expand
Yes, I didn't change the mentality.
But I also had a different version of the tactic with a very low intensity that I used when I had a comfortable lead in matches to save the conditions of the players.
Good job.
I haven't tried an Xbox version PC but I think the experience it'll be more or less like in the past FM Touch version on PC.
I think you have to copy all tactics manually only if you play in a console or a mobile but if you play on a PC then it should be Ok.
That's the only post I've found from an actual SI guy
If I had fee time then I'll look for the post I mentioned. Btw, there's also a hint in the game, it appears on the processing screen and it also says that Height also matters. Of course, as I said it might make a very small difference like 1-2% but still.
That's not true.
I remember someone asked that on the official SI forum and one of the dev team answered that a 190cm player with 15 Jumping Reach should out jump a 170 cm player with 15 Jumping Reach.
So "Height" matters after all but the tests show its impact is very small, it's really not worth bothering, there're many other attributes that have much bigger impact on the game.
It's just a few tweaks
Mentality to "Cautious"
Time Wasting to "Maximum"
Removing "Counter"
Removing "Counter-Press"
Tempo to "Minimum"
Trigger Press to "Standard"
Line Of Engagement to "Mid Block"
Also, I moved the left Striker to the left AM position.
I usually used it when I was up 2-3 goals in matches or for friendly matches.
Yes, I didn't change the mentality.
But I also had a different version of the tactic with a very low intensity that I used when I had a comfortable lead in matches to save the conditions of the players.
Also, I removed "Get Stuck In" and used only "Tackle Harder" PI - https://fm-arena.com/thread/3240-get-stuck-in-ti-vs-tackle-harder-pi/
It got me The Scudetto and Champions League Cup with Napoli
In the league I got 109 points ( only 1 draw and 1 lose ) and scored 146 goals
In the Champions League Final I defeated Man City 6 - 2
I bet that putting the WBs on "Support" duty might even further improved it.
Also, it might worth trying converting the AMs into Shadow Strikers
Have you tried it?
Yes, it's bugged as hell. Only resetting to the default helps in that case.
You can but it really doesn't work. I mean I've watched matches and different positions take the SP instead of the position picked to do that.
So, definitely, the thing doesn't work as it should.
The 6K test is coming for you!
You can't hide...
I just finished the 1st season with Man Utd.
Away matches were difficult but it should be like that.