DoubleR said: Maybe I am dumb but what do all the "top" tactics score a 5.4 specifically ? Why not one with a 5.5. and other with 5.6 etc. What causes that 5.4 number? What is it based on? What does a tactic need to do to score higher than that 5.4? Expand
The rating is just "friendly looking" points per match and to get 5.5 rating it requires achieve high enough points pet match for it.
drhay53 said: When I have low crossing on, the near post deliveries are driven in much lower than when I have whipped or floated crossing on. I have been playing on comprehensive with my own tactic for 2.5 seasons. Expand
If from that perspective then it could be... but I really doubt that.
ZaZ said: I think this is a pointless discussion. It's pretty irrelevant if he saved or not before matches for his screenshot, the only thing that counts for score is the test on FM-Arena. I have lost account of how many people come with titles like "won all trophies", "unbeatable in 300 matches", "999 goals", "best tactic in fm22" or so on, and in the end they are just average tactics, but no one complains. Expand
That's true but most of time people achieve their "amazing" results with top teams like Liverpool, Man City, Man Utd and so on and that's somehow believable but when you post like you destroy EPL with West Ham... C'mon something like that was possible when we had a ton of exploits like strikerless tactics, long throw-ins, short corner, near post corner and so on... but now? That's hardly believable.
ZaZ said: I don't see all this witch hunt in other posts with deceiving results, it's borderline bullying. Expand
Honestly, the result posted here by author is way off and that's why it got my attention.
Not often I see that people post result like they win every trophy with West Ham( 1st season ) and they had the best defense in the league with a tactic that can't have the best defense even if it's used with the best team like Liverpool or Man City and the same time he post his save where he saved the game 76 times but haven't finished the season yet and the game status shows that he used the in-game editor and the tactic got quite average rating. I'd say there are a lot of reasons to be a bit suspicious about the results.
CBP87 said: One thing I don't like is people misleading others, whether you see it as wrong or right or the fact that the only thing that is relevant is the test results. We should be honest about our own testing Expand
I complete agree with that but if you think about it, there's no way to be 100% certain whether someone cheated or not even he had saved the game 1000 times and it shows that he used the in-game editor, but when you see that the result posted by the author is drastically different from fm-arena rating then it gives serious reason to doubt. Anyway, everyone is free to make their own opinion about it.
MakeSuRE said: 1.Try to figure out how much matches it would be between 2021.07.01 and 2022.04.01. I use my pieced time to play FM so I do have to conduct a high-frequence saving schedule on prevention of any disturbance. 2.I use beauty employees mod so how can I get my beauties without editor? 3.Don’t put discrimination on anyone even you don’t like him. And don’t say any strange word to anyone you don’t even know. You know what I mean and we have duty to make this forum a pure tactic-sharing-&-downloading space. 4.Find more to prove you are right and I’m guilty for being a cheater. 5.Actually, words in ‘3’ should be told by your parents during your childhood but it seems that… oh no, I’m so sorry about that. Expand
Pal, relax.
I didn't say that you cheated, I said "it looks to me like you cheated" and it's my opinion and I might be wrong but when I look at the game status information, it's really hard for me to believe that the results you posted were achieved without cheating.
Once more, it's just my opinion and I might be wrong.
MakeSuRE said: By uploading my game save document here? Expand You can upload it on any filesharing hosting and post a download link here. I think many would like to learn from your success.
MakeSuRE said: Ruling myself out of cheating, I really would like to know how lucky I am. Expand looking into your save is the only way to know whether you cheat or not... can you upload it?
Metal said: I want to go back to fm21 but SI the cunts that they are decided to threaten a community dev to take down their work so I can't patch it to the same standards as fm22. Expand I don't get it... you mean they don't allow transfers updates or what?
Doug said: Hi - great tactic - do you know if it is as effective when dropping to attacking or positive? very exposed defensively some away games so trying to figure those games out
thanks! Expand
I think if you bet on the defense with this tactic then it only will make things worse because the key element of this tactic is a crazy attack. You try to outscore your opponent. If you don't like the amount you concede with this then I think it's better to look for other tactic with a more solid defense.
The rating is just "friendly looking" points per match and to get 5.5 rating it requires achieve high enough points pet match for it.
As I can see V2 hasn't been tested yet. Am I missing something?
If from that perspective then it could be... but I really doubt that.
No.
That's true but most of time people achieve their "amazing" results with top teams like Liverpool, Man City, Man Utd and so on and that's somehow believable but when you post like you destroy EPL with West Ham... C'mon something like that was possible when we had a ton of exploits like strikerless tactics, long throw-ins, short corner, near post corner and so on... but now? That's hardly believable.
Honestly, the result posted here by author is way off and that's why it got my attention.
Not often I see that people post result like they win every trophy with West Ham( 1st season ) and they had the best defense in the league with a tactic that can't have the best defense even if it's used with the best team like Liverpool or Man City and the same time he post his save where he saved the game 76 times but haven't finished the season yet and the game status shows that he used the in-game editor and the tactic got quite average rating. I'd say there are a lot of reasons to be a bit suspicious about the results.
I complete agree with that but if you think about it, there's no way to be 100% certain whether someone cheated or not even he had saved the game 1000 times and it shows that he used the in-game editor, but when you see that the result posted by the author is drastically different from fm-arena rating then it gives serious reason to doubt. Anyway, everyone is free to make their own opinion about it.
2.I use beauty employees mod so how can I get my beauties without editor?
3.Don’t put discrimination on anyone even you don’t like him. And don’t say any strange word to anyone you don’t even know. You know what I mean and we have duty to make this forum a pure tactic-sharing-&-downloading space.
4.Find more to prove you are right and I’m guilty for being a cheater.
5.Actually, words in ‘3’ should be told by your parents during your childhood but it seems that… oh no, I’m so sorry about that.
Pal, relax.
I didn't say that you cheated, I said "it looks to me like you cheated" and it's my opinion and I might be wrong but when I look at the game status information, it's really hard for me to believe that the results you posted were achieved without cheating.
Once more, it's just my opinion and I might be wrong.
Peace.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1HVzRCtr5q3wZy2MxYcDY4n_DW4djClWq/view?usp=sharing
I've checked your save and it looks to me like you cheated, pal.
You played only 29 matches but the game was saved 76 times.
Also, it says that the in-game editor was used in your game
Not good...
You can upload it on any filesharing hosting and post a download link here. I think many would like to learn from your success.
looking into your save is the only way to know whether you cheat or not... can you upload it?
He tested only for 20 matches, probably, just got very lucky with that... happens.
Thanks.
Do you think F9 is much better than AF in patch 22.2.0? Or it deepens?
I don't get it... you mean they don't allow transfers updates or what?
Positive Tiki Taka
Is that 4-3-3 with F9?
thanks!
I think if you bet on the defense with this tactic then it only will make things worse because the key element of this tactic is a crazy attack. You try to outscore your opponent. If you don't like the amount you concede with this then I think it's better to look for other tactic with a more solid defense.