magicnut
healmuth said: How about being constructive vs shit posting? How can I make it better? Not interested in your judgment quite frankly.


Another one with West Ham, finished 2nd in the Premier League


Don't use any kind of ramdeuters are they are usually Shit on any kind of tactics lad probably wingers attack might improve thangs for ya i guess fiddling with the playmaker perhaps a dlp instead of advanced might improve something too since the playmaker might do more defensive work ... but u should try different things and see :)

Actually another idea advanced playmaker but Support intead of attack and hold position individual instruction , this was suggested one time to me by famous tactician Lisa.
ta2199 said: That some impressive results

Second with tottenham? nothing particularly special...a good tactic can win a league first season easily..But nice he won everything on man utd :)
ta2199 said: That some impressive results

Second with tottenham? nothing particularly special...a good tactic can win a league first season easily
Cobo10 said: Yeah 1,56 it‘s OK for a 4231 with IF at the moment

It exceeded my maximum expectations by 0.01 pts!!!
Lad don't get your hopes up! Based on the results i've seen in general on this patch for 4-2-3-1 formations and especially using inside forward i'd say maximum 1.55 or so ppg more realistically 1.4ish

Cobo10 said: Do you think there is a chance for a good 4231 or 433 with IF or IW?

Given the nature of the engine id say , Nope!
I'd be shocked if something over 1.6 ever comes out..
Your tactic just tested 1.56 ppg btw
Lad don't get your hopes up! Based on the results i've seen in general on this patch for 4-2-3-1 formations and especially using inside forward i'd say maximum 1.55 or so ppg more realistically 1.4ish
Wow there , tactic has room for Improvement ! :shock: :D :devil: :vomit:
The tactical ideas are quite simular to Crackpistons  but don't seem to click quite as well :getlost:  :shock: :woot:
Skubek said: Hello patch 21.3 ?

Lad having read the patch notes I don't recall any ME changes on that patch
https://i.imgur.com/NtVhOdW.png
Hello this tactic was rated currently the highest on fmbase testing .
StephanHK made a few different tactics but it was THIS particular formation that topped their test.
https://beta.fm-base.co.uk/fm2021_12/tactic/stephenhk-tactics-fm21-521872-1999
I have checked on our list to make sure no duplicate tests already done , did not see any!
fm21.12 kung fu 4312 bbm.fmf
Downloaded : 43 times
Uploaded : Dec 2, 2020
A masterpiece!
Cerberlisk
cadoni said: @magicnut As you have see, FMB has been updated their table and Camolas isn't 1st. It's ok trying to demotivate other test leagues, but you have to be ready that isn't final and more tactics will be tested. I am not involved in FMB test league, but please..

Lad perhaps I was a bit too harsh on the fmbase testing and I really didn't mean at all to "demotivate" them . I am a little critical of fmbase due to conflicts or confrontations with certain mods there (I am banned temporarily at the moment) for cutting to the Chase and also the past audacity shown certain mods going as far as coming HERE and trying to convince me and others of their  testing methods.. I'd like to put my beef with fmbase aside since its a nice resource after all , with a few bad apples mixed in but noone is perfect :) ..

With the above said , I want to reiterate that my skepticism in fmbase testing methods is based on my own personal experience playing a few "high rated tactics" there and seeing very quickly that they weren't of much use and that's a soft way of putting it (but again this is my opinion). But this was with the very first fmbase tests done on about...fm 19 maybe ish? Not sure exactly , but when they just came out...Perhaps their new methods aren't as flawed as they were and more relevant.

Also thanks very much FMBase for giving ApePyss a whopping high ranking of 4.5 stars :)
Wow that tactic Ass...So much for fmbase testing :D ... Ofcourse I knew better by the experience I had already..
Bogeyman said: Let's hope those 3 instructions will do magic and help this to get more than 4.7 rating :)
Well unfourtunately with the new tweaks the performances dropped even further to a whopping 4.2...
So much for beating crackpistons at it's whopping 4.8 !
At minimum 3 instructions different and there might very well be differences to individual instructions although formation and roles look simular.

Bogeyman said: Let's hope those 3 instructions will do magic and help this to get more than 4.7 rating :)
I hope it can climb above CrackPistons!
At minimum 3 instructions different and there might very well be differences to individual instructions although formation and roles look simular.
Bogeyman said: isn't it the same tactic?

https://fm-arena.com/tactic/596-fm21preachinbluesknap23221-451-p101cc/


Lad upon very close and detailed inspection I can confirm this is NOT the exact same tactic:
I observed the following differences :
HIGHER defensive line vs Normal
NO offside trap
And there might be further differences in setpieces as well
ALSO : Pass into Space
Bogeyman said: isn't it the same tactic?

https://fm-arena.com/tactic/596-fm21preachinbluesknap23221-451-p101cc/


Nope lad you should look carefully the point tally is different .. Its from that same series tho. I'll load it just in case but pretty sure it's not (the tactic you sent labeled 101pts)
Hello there lads I bestow this Knapp's masterpiece which has the highest point tally of all the knapp tactics tested a whopping 110pts. Surely this might be a big hit in our leaderboards..

Source : https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1hGvdjZyrowqiMrDh9_GjVxEOpQ1AsuUk-LvwdrAIJX4/edit#gid=0
FM21PreachinBluesKnap23221(451)P110EC.fmf
Downloaded : 60 times
Uploaded : Nov 27, 2020