CBP87 said: Yeah I don't think the balanced one will reach the heights of the attacking mentality but I am intrigued to see how the underlaps work, Interesting point about underlaps/overlaps, will have to test that. I think hold up ball works hand in hand with those options though Expand
Exactly, that's why i always used Hold Up on all my Box Levante x Pirate tactics, and also in 4231 ones, glad that someone understood its potential ahah
These are the ones I will be uploading tonight hopefully
Balanced -
Underlap -
Expand
well done! not so hopeful about balanced one, cause attacking mentality showed better results almost everytime, but so curious about Underlaps or even without both Underlaps and Overlaps. I was wondering also if Dribble More on FBs could be positive or not, cause often they make risky passes to DMs losing the ball in open spaces for the opponents (so in this cases i'd prefer them to dribble past the opponent instead of trying passes) but when it comes to pass to IFs in possession phase i'd like to have less dribble attempts by defenders.
@CBP87 are you thinking trying without "Dribble More" on FBs or combination with "Underlaps" instead of "Overlaps" or neither? Last tweaks that make me wonder if 4231 could be improved anymore or not, thank you!
OneEye said: Original is fantastic for me, but this one is nowhere near as good imo. This is actually playing the game and not holiday mode. Expand
What do you mean with "the original one"? Cause also in some of my test this one performs worse than other tactics that here on FMarena are rated less, thank you!
I listened advices from someone who contacted me in private messages but also in some threads here, complaining about some top tactics with high points average but not very effective against some shapes (i.e. 433,4231,...). So i tried to build a tactic with maybe not very high points average but that should be much more consistent and successful against almost every team. In the image below you can see some of the test i did (thanks to @dzek's testing league) of my top table tactics, and computed moreover typical "Points,GF,AG,GD" also the standard deviation of the average scores, cause we dont' need a tactic which could score 78 points in a season and 65 in the next one, but the aim is to have a consistent tactic which could guarantee almost every time the same results. So maybe this one won't reach top table, but could be way more useful for ones who want a safer tactic to use against everyone.
P.S. Note that every testing league is different, so don't be surprised about 70s average scores of some tactic that here on FMArena are on 62/63/64 average points, they're simply different tests, but you can use it just as a comparison between tactics that are already tested here and this one.
FB PIs are quite different, so probably they average the same score but interaction between TIs like Overlaps/Underlaps (that mostly impact Wbs/Fbs) and PIs are different, but who knows
yep
Credits to @CBP87
Exactly, that's why i always used Hold Up on all my Box Levante x Pirate tactics, and also in 4231 ones, glad that someone understood its potential ahah
These are the ones I will be uploading tonight hopefully
Balanced -
Underlap -
well done! not so hopeful about balanced one, cause attacking mentality showed better results almost everytime, but so curious about Underlaps or even without both Underlaps and Overlaps. I was wondering also if Dribble More on FBs could be positive or not, cause often they make risky passes to DMs losing the ball in open spaces for the opponents (so in this cases i'd prefer them to dribble past the opponent instead of trying passes) but when it comes to pass to IFs in possession phase i'd like to have less dribble attempts by defenders.
By the way very good job, we'll see!
Last tweaks that make me wonder if 4231 could be improved anymore or not, thank you!
What do you mean with "the original one"? Cause also in some of my test this one performs worse than other tactics that here on FMarena are rated less, thank you!
So i tried to build a tactic with maybe not very high points average but that should be much more consistent and successful against almost every team. In the image below you can see some of the test i did (thanks to @dzek's testing league) of my top table tactics, and computed moreover typical "Points,GF,AG,GD" also the standard deviation of the average scores, cause we dont' need a tactic which could score 78 points in a season and 65 in the next one, but the aim is to have a consistent tactic which could guarantee almost every time the same results.
So maybe this one won't reach top table, but could be way more useful for ones who want a safer tactic to use against everyone.
P.S.
Note that every testing league is different, so don't be surprised about 70s average scores of some tactic that here on FMArena are on 62/63/64 average points, they're simply different tests, but you can use it just as a comparison between tactics that are already tested here and this one.
Thank You for having read it, enjoy!
Similar to my Box Levante x Pirate 2, but with attacking mentality and new TIs, removed overlap right and Run At Defence.
??
only IF and AM
RNG will ruin my day don’t worry ahah