Here's the results of No retreat no surrender Version 2 which I'm having fun using in my own save. My goal was to make a 4-3-3 with the strikers scoring the majority of goals and this seems to be doing the job. The three main advanced forwards get so many chances which I've personally witnessed in game from playing matches with the formation over version 1 that they eventually achieve a high conversion rate.
In the holiday test below you can see Ronaldo got 70 goals, rashford 29 and greenwood got 30 goals and sancho with 24 who all predominately played in the front three supplied by the ss,box to box midfielders and wingbacks. So that's 153 goals in all comps rotated between 4 players along with 146 prem league goals for Man United in 1st season no transfers.
Won the treble with United and only 2 league losses. V1 is more consistent but I got another more offensive version of the same tactic with different instructions and the wing backs on attack (version 2) but didn't win any cups but did manage to score 146 league goals which is the most I've seen tested that isn't with PSG or Liverpool on this patch which nerfs attacking intent.
This one seems more stable defensively as only conceded 25 goals where as V2 which I will later post conceded 36 goals in the league
1st season played all games no resets and won everything with this tactic alone, no positive mentality no changing the dm just relentless very attacking bulldozing teams both big and small
You need to sue knap for claiming and plagiarising your tactic
2Lit2Furious said: I posted it in the discord then Knap tweaked it. Would've liked some credit or acknowledgment but it is what it is. Think mine is still performing better tho Expand
Can't believe knap shamelessly stole your tactic and didn't give you any credit, should change his name to knob.
Anyway well done on the 5.1 that's a good score. Gonna test it out myself as love a good solid 4-3-3
Where did I say that I'm happy with the 1vs1 convertation rate?
I just say that if your player don't score their scoring changes then blaming the tactic would be the stupidest things to do because the tactic has nothing to do with the 1vs1 convertation rate.
P.S. I'm also not happy about the 1vs1 convertation rate. Expand
I thought you were trying to justify strikers missing chances by bringing up their attributes and morale, when in fact it doesn't matter how much composure they have or finishing ability or how happy they are, they will waste simple opportunities by hitting it wide like a sunday league pub player with a hangover or hitting it straight where the goalkeeper is positioned, and the goalies regardless of ability all pull out Neuer esque performances as they save all these 1vs1 chances it ruins the game.
I disagree with you both, there is a big problem with the 1vs1 finishing on this M.E to the point regardless of tactics, both human and AI players will miss 80% of clear cut chances it's beyond a joke. It's broken which is why you don't see any tactic achieve a high volume of total goals scored in a season. Unless you sim, your strikers will be lucky to get 40 goals in total in a attacking formation.
This is because you can regular games where you have 30 shots on goal, and only one of them will go in, while the opposition can have only a handful and score from their first successful attempt on target.
Look at the stats below for example of this
Go on SI community and see the number of complaints in the bug sections regarding 1vs1 clear cut chances being missed and it's loads. The cunts at SI nerfed the percentage of goals being scored because there were a bunch of morons complaining that strikers were scoring too many goals and headers.
I've tested it myself and is a solid tactic the players play like mad dog demons, will look forward to seeing how well your tweak does compared to the original
Man Utd, the 1st season
Champions Cup Final
This tactic is powerful.
Well done ZAZ
Impressive good to see someone trying something different.
Got any screenshots of the 185 goals?
The least you can do is a put some screenshots of your tactic and some results to go with it if you want any hope of it getting on the table
In the holiday test below you can see Ronaldo got 70 goals, rashford 29 and greenwood got 30 goals and sancho with 24 who all predominately played in the front three supplied by the ss,box to box midfielders and wingbacks. So that's 153 goals in all comps rotated between 4 players along with 146 prem league goals for Man United in 1st season no transfers.
This one seems more stable defensively as only conceded 25 goals where as V2 which I will later post conceded 36 goals in the league
You need to sue knap for claiming and plagiarising your tactic
Can't believe knap shamelessly stole your tactic and didn't give you any credit, should change his name to knob.
Anyway well done on the 5.1 that's a good score. Gonna test it out myself as love a good solid 4-3-3
Where did I say that I'm happy with the 1vs1 convertation rate?
I just say that if your player don't score their scoring changes then blaming the tactic would be the stupidest things to do because the tactic has nothing to do with the 1vs1 convertation rate.
P.S. I'm also not happy about the 1vs1 convertation rate.
I thought you were trying to justify strikers missing chances by bringing up their attributes and morale, when in fact it doesn't matter how much composure they have or finishing ability or how happy they are, they will waste simple opportunities by hitting it wide like a sunday league pub player with a hangover or hitting it straight where the goalkeeper is positioned, and the goalies regardless of ability all pull out Neuer esque performances as they save all these 1vs1 chances it ruins the game.
This is because you can regular games where you have 30 shots on goal, and only one of them will go in, while the opposition can have only a handful and score from their first successful attempt on target.
Look at the stats below for example of this
Go on SI community and see the number of complaints in the bug sections regarding 1vs1 clear cut chances being missed and it's loads. The cunts at SI nerfed the percentage of goals being scored because there were a bunch of morons complaining that strikers were scoring too many goals and headers.
5.1 is a very good score. I think that's rated the best 4-3-3 flat forward formation
You need to post new screenshots with results with the new tactic to show it's efficacy
I've tested it myself and is a solid tactic the players play like mad dog demons, will look forward to seeing how well your tweak does compared to the original
Check here
https://fm-arena.com/thread/1661-how-fm-arena-picks-tactics-for-the-testing/
Check here
https://fm-arena.com/thread/1661-how-fm-arena-picks-tactics-for-the-testing/