Nikko said: Mbappe doesn't have any rating for AMC position at all and Haaland at least has some awkward rating, also, Haaland has much better defensive and work rate attributes so I think Haaland would be a better choice as SS Expand
why would you be looking at defensive attributes for strikers? Mbappe has better versatility which will help him learn the position quicker, but to be fair overall I think they would both do the job there
I'm of the opposite opinion, I think Mbappe would be better as the SS due to his versatility and Haaland as the AF, I think Haaland is my clinical in front of goal
cjs0115 said: Created an account just to share this, only signgings I've made have been free transfers for players marked as decent or good for the relevant league I'm in.. I'll definitely get 2 promotions on the bounce using this tactic and then hopefully a third next season straight into the premier league.
I do get a lot of cards though! Expand
It's an aggressive tactic so you will get cards, but I'm curious to think what makes you think you're definitely going to get back to back promotions? its a very good tactic but going up into the championship and competing for promotion using any tactic is difficult. You will need to add quality and lots of it to compete
Mongoose F9, seeing as F9 seem to be pretty OP at the moment, I wanted to see if I could utilise an F9 within Mongoose. I've decided on the below shape as its given the best results so far, its a 41221, the F9 drops deeper creating space for the 2 shadow strikers to exploit whilst chipping in with some goals themselves.
Tested with Liverpool and won all competitions, no editors used. I will test with more teams tomorrow.
Lampochka97 said: There is no perfect and correct way to test tactics. Yes, my method is bad because I freeze players, but I do tests 3 times and if Salah misses six months and I only do 1 test, then the result will be wrong. In the 2nd test, Alisson may miss six months, the result will also change. Probably, my result is more incorrect for those who are just looking for good tactics and my tests work only for me Expand
There is nothing wrong with doing that, but I would suggest freezing the other players from other teams too. Creating the same environment each time is fine, but if you're only freezing Liverpool then it's more than likely going to be very one sided as Liverpool have the advantage, but by doing them all at least you're offering an equal playing field
Lampochka97 said: English teams are very strong in FM. if you play a lot, you will see that in the first seasons Liverpool most often wins the Champions League even under computer control Expand
I do play a lot and there is no doubt they are strong in Europe but they don't win it every time, they lack squad depth. If you're testing with Liverpool then you'll struggle if you get a few injuries
Lampochka97 said: Liverpool have the strongest squad in my opinion. Sooner or later, any team will become strong. I don't see any point in changing tactics, that is, first set tactics for a weak team, then for an average one, then for a strong one and then for a very strong one. Usually people choose one tactic and play it all their career. As the tests show, the results between the tactics are not so much different, that is, the tactics for Liverpool will not fail in Norwich. Expand
disagree with Liverpool having the strongest squad, they may possibly have the best starting 11 at a push but they lack depth and quality in depth
why would you be looking at defensive attributes for strikers? Mbappe has better versatility which will help him learn the position quicker, but to be fair overall I think they would both do the job there
https://fm-gamers.com/en/football-manager-2022-tactic
Access is denied when trying to access that link
I do get a lot of cards though!
It's an aggressive tactic so you will get cards, but I'm curious to think what makes you think you're definitely going to get back to back promotions? its a very good tactic but going up into the championship and competing for promotion using any tactic is difficult. You will need to add quality and lots of it to compete
Tested with Liverpool and won all competitions, no editors used. I will test with more teams tomorrow.
As always, would appreciate any feedback
There is nothing wrong with doing that, but I would suggest freezing the other players from other teams too. Creating the same environment each time is fine, but if you're only freezing Liverpool then it's more than likely going to be very one sided as Liverpool have the advantage, but by doing them all at least you're offering an equal playing field
I do play a lot and there is no doubt they are strong in Europe but they don't win it every time, they lack squad depth. If you're testing with Liverpool then you'll struggle if you get a few injuries
disagree with Liverpool having the strongest squad, they may possibly have the best starting 11 at a push but they lack depth and quality in depth
it shouldn't do