Sandro said: @CBP87, your set pieces is a mess.

Your tactics use Long Throw-ins but they are terrible in FM23, no one uses them.

Dude, your set pieces are terrible that's your tactics get such low scores

https://fm-arena.com/thread/3100-reliable-set-pieces-fm23/ Expand

Wow, thanks dude

Something on the lines of 'the set pieces could be improved, check out this link' may have been a little more helpful, my tactics are scoring low? would say 50 is pretty decent

Delicious said: I am pretty sure that underlap for this kind of shape is a must, pass into space is giving you free points,i can't really see what are the rules of the tactic from the screen,but at least since the "counter-press" was removed from "must to have options" things are even smoother.
You can try to check the differiecies with or without it. Expand

I would normally agree considering the test results, however just tested overlap with IWB and got my best results thus far

FM23 Mongoose v5

Changes from https://fm-arena.com/find-comment/17275/

- IW to DW
- WB att to IWB att
- Added overlap left and right
- Removed underlap left and right

The main focus of this change was to see how the IWBs would perform with overlap instead of underlap

FM23 Mongoose v4

Changes from https://fm-arena.com/find-comment/17275/

- Removed pass into space
- Removed overlap left and right
- Added underlap left and right

The main focus of this change was to see how the WBs would perform with underlap instead of overlap

FM23 Mongoose V3

Changes from https://fm-arena.com/thread/3125-return-of-the-mongoose/

- IWB att to WB Att
- DW to IW
- Removed Underlap left and right
- Added overlap left and right

@Zippo Apologies, I have submitted the wrong version of the tactic, any chance you can delete the tactic please and I will upload the correct version, it won't let me change it

Thanks

crizeKOS said: Nice, good luck! Expand

Thanks mate, appreciate that and also appreciate that there are some similarities with your XMAS tactics but I can assure you this is just an update of the FM21 tactic

!!THESE SCREENSHOTS ARE FOR FM23 MONGOOSE V2!!

Considering the 41212 seems to be performing very well, I thought it was a good time to bring back the Mongoose. https://fm-arena.com/thread/1532-mongoose-41212-139-goals-scored-salah-scoring-62-won-quadruple/

Tested with City, AM in charge of team selection and training.

Zippo said: What do you mean? Expand

I think he means the overall points score was higher than v1 but it achieved less points that v1

Thanks for testing

The Brazen Bull 442 v1

A 442 that performed very well with Napoli, will test with other teams. Osimhen scored plenty, although was surprised to see him still there at the end of the holiday test. Assistant manager in charge of training and squad selection

Tested with City, AM in charge of training and team selection (I put Haaland as ST and instructed FM to use current squad selection) Haaland scored 119 goals in all comps. I will provide more screenshots of other results once done. Undefeated in the league, played 38 won 36 drew 2. ZERO defeats in the league. No editors were used.

👏

Pearly Gates 4231

A 4231 that I've had some really good success with. I have took inspiration from other similar shapes and tactics in terms of team instructions.



Man City
Won everything with City, I know its an OP team with a cheat code up front, speaking of that cheat code he scored 110 goals in all comps



Napoli
Won Serie A and the champions league, Osimhen was top scorer before being sold for £86 million, Raspadori took the honours in the end with 32 goals, pretty confident Osimhen would've smashed the 50 goal mark


West Ham
Finished 3rd in the league and won Europa conference league, Scamacca top scored with 53 goals


Enjoy and always, please let know how you get on if you use it and where you think it can be improved

@Zoro I assume you are playing the game because you're in 24/25 season, can you share your team please so I can get a sense of the type of players you are using?

I've seen this before in previous versions, It normally got resolved by inputting your tactic holidaying until the next day then saving again

Baz said: Please test with a lesser team. Expand

You test it with a lesser team

Metal said: Not just 'bad' he will also say if the tactic is 'very very very bad' with a test table showing how bad it is.

So yes I don't need an essay explaining why some tactic is bad, plenty of tactics out which look good on paper then we test them and then we find out the hard way how bad they are Expand

I didn't say he needed to provide an essay did I? For all we know his testing league could be biased. But by stating "bad" without any further feedback is pretty turd in my opinion.

He may as well not share the results, what's the point in replying if he isn't going to be constructive about it?

Metal said: I find it constructive, straight to the point, no beating around the bush so we know not to touch the tactic. Expand

So you find someone saying "bad" as constructive??

@Lampochka97 stop being a nob and offer constructive feedback on the tactics you are testing instead of just saying bad. I mean this tactic finished 2nd with Chelsea in what seems an elite testing league and yet you state there are better tactics. How about saying "nice going, did well in my test league"