Bogeyman said: I'd suggested to be very careful with a limited testing of 38 matches because it can be very misleading and the result may easily vary up to 20 points with exactly the same tactic and the same team. I think "Offside Trap" is well proven TI in FM22 and I would think twice before dropping it off. Expand
I agree to some degree, but I also think your players need to have the correct attributes to be able to play the offside trap, I often find that mid - underdog teams simply don't have the required players to be able to be able to play it, but elite teams can still do very well with or without it
Tsubasa said: @CBP87, the OP looks really confusion. It's hard to find the difference between the versions. Also, it isn't clear which result belongs to which version. Maybe, it's better to leave only one version which works the best for you? Or you can add the difference between the version and separate the results? Expand
I've updated the OP and the tweaked post with the name of the tactic version
I've updated the set pieces, throw ins have been amended as per feedback from @Bogeyman however not fully replicated the top tactic. I have also removed use off side trap as when testing with Villa, the results were much better with Villa finishing 3rd on 84 points. Just felt more solid for them. Conceded less goals and scoring more. Ings scored 26 goals
Test Outcome
Test Data
Squad Overview
Results
Running a test now with an elite club, as always the Villa test was a holiday test, AM in charge of team selection and general training. No editor used!!
Play out of defence Hit Early Crosses Run at defence Distribute to CB and FB Use tighter marking
Added -
Work ball into box Distribute to right CB Roll it out
Updated set pieces
Tested with PSG and Villa, AM in charge of general training and team selection. I don't let the AM do individual training as I've found that the AM usually train's roles that aren't being used in the tactic. NO EDITORS WERE USED!!
PSG PSG predicted 1st, finished 1st with 112 points, 37 wins 1 draw, won the treble, losing out in the CL final to BVB. Mbappe scoring 56 goals in 57 appearances.
Villa Predicted 11th with the new update file, finished 4th. Danny Ings scoring 25 goals
it'll come down to how the tests rules then, I've had some tactics score less than what I thought was an absolute banger, I mean Brussel Sprouts did amazing in my tests but didn't even manage a 4 rating. Its just the way it is I'm afraid
The teams used may not fit the tactic as well as the others, my understanding is the teams used are quite well rounded but that might not mean they are the same quality as the team/s you used to test
Nikko said: Shadow Striker isn't a pure striker, he plays at AMC position and contributes a lot to the defense so I guess having good work rate and decent defensive attributes will be beneficent. Expand
Ah shit!! my bad, I thought the SS got carried defensively by the rest of the team but essentially he closes down the opposition as a PF would. Sorry yep, change my mind Haaland as SS and Mbappe as AF
Nikko said: Mbappe doesn't have any rating for AMC position at all and Haaland at least has some awkward rating, also, Haaland has much better defensive and work rate attributes so I think Haaland would be a better choice as SS Expand
why would you be looking at defensive attributes for strikers? Mbappe has better versatility which will help him learn the position quicker, but to be fair overall I think they would both do the job there
I'm of the opposite opinion, I think Mbappe would be better as the SS due to his versatility and Haaland as the AF, I think Haaland is my clinical in front of goal
cjs0115 said: Created an account just to share this, only signgings I've made have been free transfers for players marked as decent or good for the relevant league I'm in.. I'll definitely get 2 promotions on the bounce using this tactic and then hopefully a third next season straight into the premier league.
I do get a lot of cards though! Expand
It's an aggressive tactic so you will get cards, but I'm curious to think what makes you think you're definitely going to get back to back promotions? its a very good tactic but going up into the championship and competing for promotion using any tactic is difficult. You will need to add quality and lots of it to compete
Test Outcome
Test Data
Squad Overview
Results
I agree to some degree, but I also think your players need to have the correct attributes to be able to play the offside trap, I often find that mid - underdog teams simply don't have the required players to be able to be able to play it, but elite teams can still do very well with or without it
I've updated the OP and the tweaked post with the name of the tactic version
I've updated the set pieces, throw ins have been amended as per feedback from @Bogeyman
Test Outcome
Test Data
Squad Overview
Results
Running a test now with an elite club, as always the Villa test was a holiday test, AM in charge of team selection and general training. No editor used!!
Another one of my FM21 tactics which I have rejuvenated to compliment FM22. The FM21 version https://fm-arena.com/thread/1481-granny-poison-won-all-cups-17-conceded-in-all-comps/
Role changes -
FBs > IWBa
DLPs > DMs
BBM > CMa
IWs > Ws
TI changes -
Removed
Play out of defence
Hit Early Crosses
Run at defence
Distribute to CB and FB
Use tighter marking
Added -
Work ball into box
Distribute to right CB
Roll it out
Updated set pieces
Tested with PSG and Villa, AM in charge of general training and team selection. I don't let the AM do individual training as I've found that the AM usually train's roles that aren't being used in the tactic. NO EDITORS WERE USED!!
PSG
PSG predicted 1st, finished 1st with 112 points, 37 wins 1 draw, won the treble, losing out in the CL final to BVB. Mbappe scoring 56 goals in 57 appearances.
Villa
Predicted 11th with the new update file, finished 4th. Danny Ings scoring 25 goals
I will add more test results from other teams
Leeds may have suited the shape and style of the tactic, try using with Norwich to get a sense of how an underdog would perform using it
Ah shit!! my bad, I thought the SS got carried defensively by the rest of the team but essentially he closes down the opposition as a PF would. Sorry yep, change my mind Haaland as SS and Mbappe as AF
why would you be looking at defensive attributes for strikers? Mbappe has better versatility which will help him learn the position quicker, but to be fair overall I think they would both do the job there
https://fm-gamers.com/en/football-manager-2022-tactic
Access is denied when trying to access that link
I do get a lot of cards though!
It's an aggressive tactic so you will get cards, but I'm curious to think what makes you think you're definitely going to get back to back promotions? its a very good tactic but going up into the championship and competing for promotion using any tactic is difficult. You will need to add quality and lots of it to compete