Temperamental Temperament 1-4, Professionalism 1-10 This personality trumps pretty much every single other one, so if they are not temperamental, they don't have these attributes.
Im also interesting to see what our gurus from this forum can say about this topic.. I would also ask you guys what are the best personalities to be mentors? I know model citizen is the best one, but what about the others?
When i say good result im comparing with last FMs.. I think you agree with me that in past versions with a single tactic you could win everything, right?
Of course that good players also helps a lot, but im just saying that there is a balance between good players and good tactic.. Maybe on this version is something like 70% weight on good players and 30% tactic, however in past versions i would say its the opposite.
Hey.. im using this tactic (v3) but im getting a lot of yellow/red cards:
Is there anyway i can tweak this to avoid getting so many cards? during game im already changing the tackling to "ease off tackles" when someone gets booked, but still having a lot of cards as you can see
ZaZ said: The highest the attributes of a player at early age, the highest the chance to have high potential. Remember that players grow extremely fast until 18, then they grow just fast until 23, then slow until 27, and after that their growth usually stop. Expand
Got it.. but should i give higher importance to certain attributes?
Pikabo said: Tactical Real CA. Basically it should calculate player's usefulness on the position based on his attributes using the ykyky balanced table for attribute weighing. Post#113 on page 4 should give you any idea of how to do it and then Mark made it more graphical in post #285 on page 10. Expand
got it, thanks.. but in Mark's post (page 4, #113) he's subtracting the formula by 121. any ideia why the 121 specifically?
Mark said: I decided to try and find a way to get best value for money for buying players. I have used the ykykyky ratings file which finds the best players by position, I know just using acceleration and pace will result in pretty good players especially in lower divisions. What I decided to focus on was attributes with low CA cost, using the attribute cost table, but big positional impact ie high weighting in the ykykyky rating file. I only looked at rating weights of 50 or higher.
I then ranked the attributes after calculating the attribute weight divided by CA cost.
I think the attribute scores that are above 15 are the ones to use. I have been using the Division average and adding a point or 2 and searching for players. I seem to be getting pretty good players using this approach. My most recent save is tier 8 in the English system. I struggled early and was 6 wins 2 draws and 2 losses after the first 10 games. I restarted the save and bought 10 players using this approach, to cover all outfield positions using ZaZ Blue 4.0. Won the first 10 games.
If you give it a try, please let me know how you go. Expand
Hey @Mark sorry but im feeling quite stupid today What you're saying is that the best attribute per position (CA cost wise) would be Vision for DCs, Off the ball for DRL and so on? Meaning, if i only train these attributes i will get my players to the best performance possible instead of just train them for quickness. Am I wrong?
Hi guys, i know that CM Mezzala is not in this tactic, but i use it on my own tactic - would you recommend the same attributes as a DM in this table? if not, what would you consider to be the top 5 attributes?
Hi, I've found out a tactic in FM Scout which is very promising. Accordingly to the results, its goals galore:
Tactic:
Results:
Also an youtube video from the creator of the tactic with some detailed explanation:
To reinforce: this tactic is not mine and i did no changes at all, but it would be cool to share with you and maybe test it. Im curious with the results.
Alexis said: I'm sorry if this is a dumb question, but I'm not sure I understand... Does this new way of testing tactics give a more accurate rating than before, or is it just a different way of evaluating the tactic, without necessarily being more accurate? Expand
Player Personalities:
Spoiler Ambitious
Ambition 16-19, Loyalty 7-9
Determination <18, Professionalism <18, Leadership <19
Balanced
Balanced is pretty much anything that doesn't fall under another label. Also covers all negative personalities for real life players.
Born Leader
Leadership 20, Determination 20
This trumps the perfectionist trait, but not model citizen or temperamental.
Casual
Determination 1-9, Professionalism 2-4
Leadership<19, Temperament >4
Charismatic Leader
Leadership 19-20, Temperament18-20, Sportsmanship 18-20
Determined
Determination 18-20,
Ambition <12, Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Devoted
Ambition 6-7, Loyalty 20. *Must also be at a favourite club.
Determination 6-17, Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Driven
Determination 18-20, Ambition 12-20
Easily Discouraged
Determination 1, Ambition 1-9
Fairly Ambitious
Ambition 15-20, Loyalty 10-20
Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Fairly Determined
Determination 15-17
Professionalism <15, Leader <19
Fairly Loyal
Loyalty 15-20, Ambition 8-14
Determination 6-15, Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Fairly Professional
Professionalism 15-17, Temperament 11-20
or Professionalism 18-20, Temperamemt 1-10
Fairly Sporting
Sportsmanship 15-20, Determination 10-14, Ambition 1-14
Professionalism <15
Fickle
Loyalty 4-6, Ambition 16-20
Determination <17, Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Honest
Sportsmanship 20, Determination 1-9
Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Iron Willed
Pressure 20, Determination 15-17
Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Jovial
Pressure 15-20, Determination 1-17
Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Leader
Leadership 19-20
Light Hearted
Pressure 15-20, Sportsmanship 15-20
Determination <18, Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Low Determination
Determination 1-5
Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Low Self Belief
Professionalism 2-3, Determination 1-9
Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Loyal
Loyalty 18-19, Ambition 6-7
Determination <18, Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Mercenary
Loyalty 1-3, Ambition 16-20
Determination <18, Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Model Citizen
Determination 14-20, Professionalism 15-20, Ambition 12-20, Loyalty 15-20, Pressure 14-20, Sportsmanship 15-20, Temperament 15-20
Model Professional
Professionalism 20, Temperament 10-20
Perfectionist
Determination 14-20, Professionalism 14-20, Ambition 14-20
Professional
Professionalism 18-19, Temperament 10-20
Leader <19
Realist
Sportsmanship 2-5, Determination 11-17
Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Resiliant
Pressure 17-19, Determination 15-17
Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Resolute
Determination 15-17, Proffessionalism 15-17
Leader <19
Slack
Professionalism 1, Determination 1-9
Temperament >4, Leader <19
Spineless
Pressure 1, Determination 1-9
Leader <19
Spirited
Pressure 15-20, Professionalism 11-17
Determination <18, Leader <19
Sporting
Sportsmanship 18-19, Determination 1-9
Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Temperamental
Temperament 1-4, Professionalism 1-10
This personality trumps pretty much every single other one, so if they are not temperamental, they don't have these attributes.
Unambitious
Ambition 1-5, Loyalty 11-20
Determination <18, Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Unsporting
Sportsmanship 1, Determination 11-17
Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Very Ambitious
Ambition 20, Loyalty 7-9
Determination <18, Professionalism <18, Leader <19
Very Loyal
Loyalty 20, Ambition 6-7
Determination <18, Professionalism <18, Leader <19
You've just mentioned all the possible personalities, whereas i've asked for the best ones....
Of course that good players also helps a lot, but im just saying that there is a balance between good players and good tactic.. Maybe on this version is something like 70% weight on good players and 30% tactic, however in past versions i would say its the opposite.
Dont you agree?
I'm sure you'll win the league easily.
Wouldn't it be a good result? So what's the problem?
I think that a good result would be win everything with a team like PSG...
Also a good result would be picking up Angers or something like that and be league champion
Is there anyway i can tweak this to avoid getting so many cards? during game im already changing the tackling to "ease off tackles" when someone gets booked, but still having a lot of cards as you can see
Got it.. but should i give higher importance to certain attributes?
I've started with a low league team, therefore my scouts ability are, for lack of a better word, questionable.
Therefore i want to know, besides reading personalities and media description, how can i spot that an 15/16 years old regen has a good potential?
Usually i only look to the Determination and Acc/Pace attributes. Am i doing anything wrong here?
got it, thanks.. but in Mark's post (page 4, #113) he's subtracting the formula by 121. any ideia why the 121 specifically?
Thanks
I then ranked the attributes after calculating the attribute weight divided by CA cost.
I think the attribute scores that are above 15 are the ones to use. I have been using the Division average and adding a point or 2 and searching for players. I seem to be getting pretty good players using this approach. My most recent save is tier 8 in the English system. I struggled early and was 6 wins 2 draws and 2 losses after the first 10 games. I restarted the save and bought 10 players using this approach, to cover all outfield positions using ZaZ Blue 4.0. Won the first 10 games.
If you give it a try, please let me know how you go.
Hey @Mark sorry but im feeling quite stupid today
Accordingly to Zippo, we need to have a different topic to test the 433 version - do you want to do it, since you share it here first?
Cagado said: Here the 433 version for me its better then any tactic i have played, it is from the same source and credits to Stephenhk
Tactic:
Results:
Also an youtube video from the creator of the tactic with some detailed explanation:
To reinforce: this tactic is not mine and i did no changes at all, but it would be cool to share with you and maybe test it. Im curious with the results.
Read the first post!
Would this make sense?
Im constantly receiving "complains" from a lot of players asking to have more strenght training
Are there any training schedules you would recomend using? I've seen a bunch of training schedules but for full timers only