CBP87
Tweaked version of https://fm-arena.com/thread/9042-katana-4231-104p-v3-3/

Changes -
Added narrow width
Removed shoot less often from FBs
Removed get further forward from DM
Added sit narrower and roam from position to IFs







Carl said: Why not create a tactic with Midfielders

Because it doesn't work as effective as a tactic with defensive midfielders, the double pivot is very OP and I have created tactics with central midfielders and the tactics were no way near as effective as tactics with defensive midfielders.

I'm pretty sure you've asked me this question before
Tweaked version of https://fm-arena.com/thread/9170-katana-4231-p100-v5-0/

Changes -

VOL attack to VOL support
FB support to FB attack
Take more risks, sit narrower, dribble more and shoot less often added to FB
Dribble more and move into channels added to VOL
Sit narrower removed from IF
Dribble more, roam from position and move into channels added to AM







Tweaked version of https://fm-arena.com/thread/9025-katana-4231-104p-v3-1/

Changes-
Tempo to lower
Removed counter
Width changed to fairly narrow







Tweaked version of https://fm-arena.com/thread/9025-katana-4231-104p-v3-1/

I'm not saying it won't work for mid/underdog teams but this appears to work better with elite teams. Only 17 conceded in the league

Changes -
Lower tempo
Removed counter







Tweaked version of https://fm-arena.com/thread/9125-katana-4231-100p-v3-1-1/

Katana 4231 93p v3.1.5

Changes-
Removed dribble more from DMs
Removed move into channels for AM
Added run wide with ball to FBs







Tweaked version of https://fm-arena.com/thread/9025-katana-4231-104p-v3-1/

Changes -

Removed focus down flanks
BPDd to BPDc







Droid said: Nope, we don't capture that information.

But if you're really intrigued that much :) then you can calculate it yourself.

It only requires to calculate PPM(Points Per Match) from the first 3 tests and them multiply by 38 and you'll get the score after 1,200 matches.


Peter78 said: @CBP87  did you see any noticeable difference between mentalities and if so would you recommend starting and staying with Attacking, or varying between Balanced at start and changing depending on how the game is going?

Hey, I would stick with attacking but adjust other aspect of the instructions. For example, difficult  away games, I take off prevent short gk distribution and counter press and that seems to help
Did anyone notice what score it got at 1200 and 2400 matches please? @Zippo @Droid do you guys capture that information anywhere? Just intrigued if there was a point swing
Tweaked version of https://fm-arena.com/thread/9184-katana-4231-109p-v3-1-12/

Changes -
Removed take more risks from DM
Added sit narrower to FBs
Removed shoot less often, stay wider, run wide with ball, dribble more and take more risks from FB

Pretty much used the PIs for the FBs from https://fm-arena.com/thread/9100-cosmos-71-p107-4231/ to try and replicate the defensive solidity the tactic showed in testing







Gianaa9 said: wow, pay attention to this e.e

I suspect it will drop, hopefully not, but the likelihood is that it will
Tweaked version of https://fm-arena.com/thread/9025-katana-4231-104p-v3-1/

Changes-
Width changed to narrow







Tweaked version of https://fm-arena.com/thread/9025-katana-4231-104p-v3-1/

Changes -
Removed overlap
Added underlap
Stay wider added to IFs
DMs changes to VOLa
FBa changed to FBs







MA91 said: Do you use same Attacking mentality away as well? or maybe any SUS tactic?

Yeah I tend to stick with the same instructions unless I'm struggling against a team that is parking the bus, I switch to slightly lower tempo
impersonal2556 said: player instructions?

Grintar said: Tempo is standard or a little higher...try these settings?

Try slightly lower
Grintar said: Well, as a rule, everything is often fine against big teams... but against weak teams, the loss of points begins... what is the best mentality to use then? Thank you

Ok this is something I've struggled wit as well because they tend to park the bus against you. I found lowering the tempo to slightly lower helps as you retain the ball which hopefully in turns draws a player out of position for you to exploit. In my current Barca save I found this against every team I came up against so reduced the tempo to slightly lower and I've lost 1 game in 2 seasons in the league
Grintar said: And one more question: how to deal with the result on the road? I play for Lazio and sometimes it’s a complete disaster on the road

Depends on who you are playing, but remember your squad has a lot to do it, are you expected to lose? who are you coming up against? Inter? Milan? Juve?
Grintar said: Hello, can you tell me if the results are affected somehow if you play through a quick result or still watch the whole match?

Hello, I use instant result most of the time and the tactic performs fine, only difference with you playing the game would be the shouts and decisions you are making during the game