Your original Katana tactic hit 2.4 points positive RNG so to beat it at least by 1 point you need a tactic that would be better than your Katana by 2.4 points and also you need to hit at least 1 point positive RNG... I'd say that taks is almost imposibble
ZaZ said: Just as a reminder, the fact that one attribute did not get impressive results in the table of FM-Arena does not mean that attribute is useless. For example, stamina might be impactful only for two or three players, like DM and WBs, which represents less than 30% of the team. In that case, even if Stamina is as impactful as Pace and Acceleration for those positions, it will still give worse results than attributes that have impact across all roles. Expand
No way that Stamina can be impactful as Acceleration and Pace for any positions.
In the FM-Arena test Stamina attribute was increased by 5 points for every positions including the DMs and WBs and that improved the result just by 2 points from 60 pts to 62 pts, which honestly can be just the RNG but when Acceleration or Pace attributes were increased by 5 then it improved the result by 21 points from 60 pts to 81 pts.
So no way Stamina attribute or any other attribute can be as impactful as Pace and Acceleration for any position.
Gianaa9 said: You sure? I noticed that with attacking mentality the shapes automatically become wider, and narrower with more defensive ones, and in my test usually the more is narrow the team's shape, the less are goal scored and against goals.. Also if you read on TI menu, when you have to set the shape and you leave the standard one, it says "it will adapt to team's menatlity", and if you try to change mentality you can see that with attacking the standard is "fairly wide", with defensive "narrow", etc... Expand
The Mentality might affect the attacking and defensive shapes at the same time.
I was talking about the setting below, which I'm 100% sure only affects the attacking shape.
db782 said: The tactic has been amazing so far, only issue is my advanced forward is really struggling to score as much as you'd expect, from 30 games he has 9 goals - the striker is a regen wonderkid who has fantastic attributes 15+ across the board - anyone else having similar issues? he could also play pressing forward would this player role be as effective? Expand
It depends on the league you play in.
For example, if you play in EPL then 15+ Acc, Pace and Dribbling wouldn't be "fantastic" at all for such strong league, it would be just average.
Not all attributes matters there are some meta attributes that makes a huge difference.
fmOG said: im using this and having bad results, cant figure it out why Expand
The thing is, that the results that you consider as "bad", actually might be "good" or at least "normal" but you just don't understand it due to lack of knowledge how the game works.
SCF said: Is it possible for hidden attributes (like consistency) to improve for a player? Expand
Many hidden attributes can be improved throughout Mentoring.
Btw, I'm not sure that Consistency can be improved throughout Mentoring but I almost sure that players slightly improve their Consistency attribute during their careers, but don't expect a miracle here, maybe they get +1 Consistency every 3-4 seasons or something like that.
Consistency determine how many matches a player plays at his full CA.
20 Consistency mean that a player plays 20 matches of 25 and his full CA and 5 matches his CA decreased by random number from 1 to 20.
10 Consistency mean that a player plays 10 matches of 25 and his full CA and 15 matches his CA decreased by random number from 1 to 20.
White Europe said: Guys, anyone try any match plans with success here? Not the ones included in game but did anyone use own match plans when playing with instant result? Expand
Honestly, I always thought that Match Plans thing works properly only in FM Touch version when you use Instant Result.
Since FM Touch version stopped be available through Steam for PC I didn't bother with Match Plans and Instant Result.
But I think Match Plans and Instant Result are very good features but it's really embarrassing how SI treats good features in their game.
Your original Katana tactic hit 2.4 points positive RNG so to beat it at least by 1 point you need a tactic that would be better than your Katana by 2.4 points and also you need to hit at least 1 point positive RNG... I'd say that taks is almost imposibble
He already said that the positions have only 2 PIs: Dribble More and Tackle Harder.
"Get Stuck In" ( TI ) vs "Tackle Harder" ( PI ) - https://fm-arena.com/thread/3240-get-stuck-in-ti-vs-tackle-harder-pi/
Long story short: Get Stuck In(TI) = Tackle Harder(PI)
Should you follow the highlighted attributes of the roles?(PART 1) - https://fm-arena.com/thread/5351-should-you-follow-the-highlighted-attributes-of-the-roles/
Should you follow the highlighted attributes of the roles?(PART 2) - https://fm-arena.com/find-comment/23204/
Game-changing Player Attributes - https://fm-arena.com/thread/2980-game-changing-player-attributes/
What it takes to dominate EPL with Bournemouth - https://fm-arena.com/thread/3293-what-it-takes-to-dominate-epl-with-bournemouth/
FM24 Player Attributes Testing - https://fm-arena.com/table/26-player-attributes-testing/
No way that Stamina can be impactful as Acceleration and Pace for any positions.
In the FM-Arena test Stamina attribute was increased by 5 points for every positions including the DMs and WBs and that improved the result just by 2 points from 60 pts to 62 pts, which honestly can be just the RNG but when Acceleration or Pace attributes were increased by 5 then it improved the result by 21 points from 60 pts to 81 pts.
So no way Stamina attribute or any other attribute can be as impactful as Pace and Acceleration for any position.
Pace - https://fm-arena.com/tactic/7528-5-points-to-pace-for-all-positions/
Acceleration - https://fm-arena.com/tactic/7527-5-points-to-acceleration-for-all-positions/
Stamina - https://fm-arena.com/tactic/7557-5-points-to-stamina-for-all-positions/
Here's another test when Acceleration and Pace was tested, specifically, for Central Midfielder position - https://fm-arena.com/thread/5351-should-you-follow-the-highlighted-attributes-of-the-roles/
Hi,
I wonder why don't you say exactly what PIs you added/removed.
@Zippo @Droid according to this - https://fm-arena.com/thread/2733-how-to-get-your-tactic-tested/ people must write up the changes they make but I've been noticing some people ignore that requirement. I think there must be some kind of "punishments" for that.
Also if you read on TI menu, when you have to set the shape and you leave the standard one, it says "it will adapt to team's menatlity", and if you try to change mentality you can see that with attacking the standard is "fairly wide", with defensive "narrow", etc...
The Mentality might affect the attacking and defensive shapes at the same time.
I was talking about the setting below, which I'm 100% sure only affects the attacking shape.
The width setting only affects the shape when the team "has the ball" and it doesn't have any impact on "without the ball" shape.
It depends on the league you play in.
For example, if you play in EPL then 15+ Acc, Pace and Dribbling wouldn't be "fantastic" at all for such strong league, it would be just average.
Not all attributes matters there are some meta attributes that makes a huge difference.
https://fm-arena.com/thread/8249-fm24-meta-player-attributes/
https://fm-arena.com/thread/5351-should-you-follow-the-highlighted-attributes-of-the-roles/
https://fm-arena.com/table/26-player-attributes-testing/
At the 1st season West Ham is predicted to finish the 10th place.
If you end up the 1st season with this tactic higher than the 10th then it can be considered as "working".
But if you expect to get 100+ points with the default West Ham team as it stands in the 1st season then I suggest you to read this - https://fm-arena.com/thread/1076-my-tactic-doesn-t-work-help-me-please/
The thing is, that the results that you consider as "bad", actually might be "good" or at least "normal" but you just don't understand it due to lack of knowledge how the game works.
Here's more info about the subject - https://fm-arena.com/thread/1076-my-tactic-doesn-t-work-help-me-please/
CA doesn't mean anything.
120CA player might be much better than 160CA player
Look at the threads below for more info:
https://fm-arena.com/thread/8249-fm24-meta-player-attributes/
https://fm-arena.com/thread/5351-should-you-follow-the-highlighted-attributes-of-the-roles/
https://fm-arena.com/thread/2980-game-changing-player-attributes/
Also, look at this - https://fm-arena.com/thread/1076-my-tactic-doesn-t-work-help-me-please/
I guess, if it's "Approved" and added to the queue then you can't edit it
But I must add that I'm very missing FM Touch version, I wish it was available on Steam for PC users.
My opinion, that the full game version has much more useless, complicated and boring stuff that the FM Touch version.
https://fm-arena.com/thread/8836-the-tactic-testing-league-has-been-updated/
Many hidden attributes can be improved throughout Mentoring.
Btw, I'm not sure that Consistency can be improved throughout Mentoring but I almost sure that players slightly improve their Consistency attribute during their careers, but don't expect a miracle here, maybe they get +1 Consistency every 3-4 seasons or something like that.
Consistency determine how many matches a player plays at his full CA.
20 Consistency mean that a player plays 20 matches of 25 and his full CA and 5 matches his CA decreased by random number from 1 to 20.
10 Consistency mean that a player plays 10 matches of 25 and his full CA and 15 matches his CA decreased by random number from 1 to 20.
and so on...
Honestly, I always thought that Match Plans thing works properly only in FM Touch version when you use Instant Result.
Since FM Touch version stopped be available through Steam for PC I didn't bother with Match Plans and Instant Result.
But I think Match Plans and Instant Result are very good features but it's really embarrassing how SI treats good features in their game.
https://fm-arena.com/thread/8836-the-tactic-testing-league-has-been-updated/
https://fm-arena.com/thread/8836-the-tactic-testing-league-has-been-updated/
I suggest using any in-game editor to find out things such as CP and PA.